I continue the fight for them

I continue the fight for them
Daylen and Grandad at the beach

Saturday, April 23, 2011

More on collegiate athletics and it's role in the universities

Again, if you want to verify an organizations priorities then look at the check book and see where the money is spent.

From the Wall Street Journal:
By FRED BARNES
Sports Illustrated/Getty Images
University of Alabama football coach Nick Saban with the Crimson Tide before a 2010 game against the San Jose State Spartans at Bryant-Denny Stadium. 

Pity the poor presidents of colleges with major athletic programs. Football coaches are not just better known than the administrators, the coaches also tend to make a lot more money. And professors lag even further behind. In 1986, the presidents at 44 public universities with teams in the five most established athletic conferences actually made, on average, a little more than their coaches: $294,000 for the presidents, $273,000 for the coaches; full professors earned about $107,000. By 2010, the professors' income, adjusted for inflation, had climbed 32%. University presidents' pay had gone up 90%. The football coaches' pay jumped to more than $2 million—it had "increased by an astounding seven and a half times," Charles T. Clotfelter writes in "Big-Time Sports in American Universities."

Mr. Clotfelter cites coaches' contracts packed with incentives: Nick Saban's 2010 agreement with the University of Alabama, for instance, included bonuses of $125,000 for winning the Southeastern Conference championship and $200,000 for taking the Crimson Tide to a BCS bowl game. The book offers plenty of other eye-opening statistics but is perhaps most surprising in its even-handed approach to the subject of major college athletics.
Mr. Clotfelter is, after all, a professor of public policy and of economics and law at Duke University. Faculty members are often hostile to college sports. But Mr. Clotfelter took a novel tack: "I decided to employ my skills as a social scientist to ask the same elementary questions about big-time college athletics that might be posed by a first-time visitor to this country."

He wondered, for instance, whether the seemingly lopsided media coverage of college sports—when compared with attention to other aspects of higher education—is a relatively recent phenomenon. Certainly the media emphasis on big-time college sports is now pronounced: Mr. Clotfelter looked at the New York Times's coverage of 58 universities with major programs and found that the paper devoted seven times as much attention to sports as to other topics concerning the schools. But it was ever thus. Mr. Clotfelter went back 40 years and then 80 years and found a similar disparity in the Times's coverage of the same schools. Sports wins, archeology gets left in the dust. Complaints about the outsize importance of college sports, he notes, go back more than a century.

The book's central theme is that the time has come to end the strange dichotomy on college campuses, where athletic and educational departments exist in parallel universes and regard each other warily. University leaders "typically ignore" athletics "when putting together a formal statement listing their institution's essential functions and objectives."

The unwillingness to acknowledge the centrality of major sports on many campuses makes no sense. Football and basketball teams are, for starters, a huge physical presence, with their gigantic stadiums (Bryant-Denny Stadium at Alabama seats 102,000) and large arenas (the Dean Dome at the University of North Carolina holds nearly 22,000). "Whether or not universities like to admit it," Mr. Clotfelter says, "big-time athletics must be counted as one of their significant activities."

Big-Time Sports In American Universities

By Charles T. Clotfelter
Cambridge, 313 pages, $29
And one of their significant economic centers. The author notes that critics complain "how few big-time programs break even or make a profit." Sounds scandalous, right? Despite millions that pour in from TV contracts, merchandise and ticket sales, and other sources, athletic departments barely make ends meet. But as Mr. Clotfelter observes, "arbitrary administrative decisions"—like billing the athletic department for students' phys-ed classes—muddle any net-profit analysis. And there's no way to measure the role that a high-profile team might play in attracting better students and alumni donations.

Heaven knows, there are problems. Athletes receive shockingly preferential treatment—they take easy courses, and if those prove too difficult tutors practically carry them over the goal-line to a passing grade. Despite the help, many athletes are simply out of place in an institution of higher learning and don't graduate. At 58 universities with major athletic programs in 2010, 72% of students graduated, but only 56% of football players and 42% of basketball players received a diploma.

The biggest source of trouble for college sports, however, is the NCAA's insistence that athletes remain unpaid amateurs. Coaches desperate for stars to keep programs competitive will, with the help of eager alumni, do almost anything to sign player and keep them happy. New cars, rent-free apartments and no-show jobs are some of the inducements—in violation of NCAA rules. A recent example: The University of Connecticut basketball team won the national championship earlier this month, but coach Jim Calhoun has been barred from the first three games next season for recruiting infractions that involved a former team manager giving lodging, transportation and meals to a promising recruit.

"Big-Time Sports in American Universities" doesn't sugarcoat the downside. Mr. Clotfelter contends, though, that college sports transcends its shortcomings. "For all its flaws—and these are real—big-time college sports also produces a great deal of enjoyment," he says. "In a word, it produces happiness." The enjoyment spreads beyond students to entire communities. And valuable lessons are taught. "Embodied in college sports," he says, "is the principle of meritocracy."

Overshadowed and less-well-remunerated college presidents and faculty might find that message hard to swallow, but it's in their interest to hope that, in the meritocracy of college sports, their team wins.
—Mr. Barnes is executive editor of the Weekly Standard.

Update on Pension Reform

From the WALL STREET JOURNAL

Earlier this week, the Arizona state Senate joined the House in approving a measure that will pare back the costs of government retirement benefits.

The catalyst for the reform, which GOP Gov. Jan Brewer has said she will sign, came from reports in the Arizona Republic that pension expenses now cost the state nearly $1.4 billion a year and that retirement trust fund reserves fall far below private industry standards for soundness. Lawmakers also discovered that some of the retirement trust funds were near depletion because of heavy losses during the stock market meltdown in 2008. For the past two years Arizona has had the largest fiscal deficit as a share of its budget of any state.

The pension bill will require certain workers, such as firefighters and police officers, to increase their contributions for benefits to more than 11 percent of salary, up from 7.65 percent today. The bill also protects against double dipping and would suspend automatic cost-of-living benefit elevators in years when the investment fund earns less than a 10.5 percent return.

The measure didn't cause protests in the streets as it did in Wisconsin, but the cost-saving measures will almost certainly invoke lawsuits by the public employee unions. The union bosses hope for an injunction from the courts because the state constitution prohibits the legislature from altering current benefits.

"It's a good start and a victory," says Steve Voeller, who heads the Free Enterprise Club, an advocacy group. "It doesn't go far enough in trimming benefits for current workers, [but] at least we have the advantage of being a right-to-work-state."

___________________________________________________
also reported in the Az Republic:

New hires beginning July 2011, will not be officially enrolled in ASRS until they have completed 6 months of employment.

Current 85 points rule, needed for 100% benefits has been changed as of July 2011.  New enrolls will not receive full benefits until they reach age 65, age 62 with at least 10 years of experience, or age 55 with at least 30 years experience.  Retirement amount received will not exceed 75% of the average yearly salary.

Also, employers that hire a "double-dipper" will be mandated to pay the retirement contribution for that retiree.  Looks like double-dipping will end, unless school districts can justify a substantial loss to their yearly budget.

Stay alert and informed as there will be a push to change the amendment to the constitution that forbids any change to your current benefits (that is for those already retired).  If this thing goes to the voters, we may be 'toast'.

The governor approved all suggested changes:

https://www.azasrs.gov/content/pdf/2011_legislation_summary.pdf

Friday, April 22, 2011

Easter, the most profound event in human history

Two thousand years ago, a guy named Jesus, a few hours after having dinner with his closest friends, knelt to pray in a garden.  Some people interrupted his quiet.  They arrested him.  They put him on trial.  They nailed him to a cross.  They killed him.  Three days later he conquered death, rose again from death, and freed the world.  He died that we might live.

Some hear the story of the Christ and hear myth.  Others hear it and believe.  Honestly, while it matters, for our context here it does not matter.  It just is.  Whether you believe it or not, the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ is the most profound event in human history.  Empires were built—forged on faith in his name.  Arts and sciences grew and prospered as products of faith.  Philosophers and kings lived and died in ways that would have been dramatically different, but for that act on Calvary.

Today, in the United States, we struggle as perhaps the last religious people in western society.  The concept of the puritan work ethic has defined us as a nation and, through it, the doctrine of vocation premised on what some see as a near divine right or blessing within this country, has allowed us to prosper.  But, as you read this, more and more Americans get their wealth from government.  Not since the Great Depression have more Americans taken from the treasury than given to the treasury.  The puritan work ethic and the Christian ethos of America are slowly replaced by dependency on government and the secular god of tolerance wherein everything is embraced save everlasting Truth.

When you go out today on Good Friday, remember that two thousand years ago, one act changed forever the course of human history.  But for it, this country we have would not have happened in the way it did or with the character it has.  And the cool part is, while some may choose to call it fiction, so many more have believed and acted accordingly, the timeline of human history itself has been impacted in so many positive ways.  The death and resurrection of Christ remains the greatest act of sovereign grace ever displayed in the universe and also the biggest story that ever will be.
— Erick Erickson

Saturday, April 16, 2011

Which BCS Schools/Conferences Are Committed To Academic Excellence? (Part 2)

Rankings for the 15 different academic programs

Business
1. Stanford (50) 5-tie Northwestern (45.5) 7-tie California (43.5) 
12. Duke (39) 13. Virginia (38) 14. UCLA (37) 15. Michigan (36) 17. Texas (34) 
19. North Carol. (32) 21-tie Minnesota (29.5) 21-tie USC (29.5) 23-tie Indiana (28) 
25-tie Ohio State (25.5) 27. Ariz State (24) 28-tie Georgia Tech (21.5) 
28-tie Wisconsin (21.5) 28-tie Vanderbilt (21.5) 32-tie BYU (18.5)
32-tie Texas AM (18.5) 34. Boston College (17) 37-tie Illinois (13) 
37-tie Notre Dame (13) 37-tie Washington (13) 40-tie Penn State (10.5) 
40-tie Iowa (10.5)  45-tie Maryland(6) 47-tie Florida (3.5) 
47-tie Wake Forest (3.5) 49-tie Mich. State (1.5) 49-tie Purdue (1.5)

Political Science
1-tie Stanford (49) 4. Michigan (47) 6. California (45) 9-tie Duke (41.5) 
11-tie UCLA (39.5) 13-tie North Carol. (37.5) 15-tie Wisconsin (35.5) 
17-tie Minnesota (33) 17-tie Ohio State (33) 21-tie Northwestern (29) 
21-tie Illinois (29) 21-tie Texas (29) 24-tie Texas AM (26.5) 
26-tie Washington (24.5) 26-tie Indiana (24.5)
28-tie Mich. State (21.5) 28-tie Penn State (21.5) 28-tie Maryland (21.5)
33-tie Iowa (17.5) 33-tie Virginia (17.5) 36-tie Notre Dame (14)
39-tie Flor. State (5.9) 39-tie Colorado (5.9) 39-tie Pitt (5.9) 
39-tie Vanderbilt (5.9) 46-tie Arizona (4.5) 48. Rutgers (3)

Education
1. Vanderbilt (50) 2-tie Texas (48.5) 4-tie Stanford (46.5) 
6. UCLA (45) 7. Northwestern (44) 8. Oregon (43) 
9-tie Michigan (41.5)  9-tie Washington (41.5) 
11. Wisconsin (40) 12-tie California (38.5) 14. USC (37) 
15-tie Boston College (35.5) 17. Mich. State (34)
18-tie Kansas (32.5) 20. Ohio State (31) 21. Indiana (30) 22. Virginia (29) 23-tie Illinois (27) 23-tie Maryland (27) 23-tie Pitt (27) 
26-tie Penn State (24.5) 28. Minnesota (23) 29-tie Iowa (20.5)
29-tie North Carol. (20.5) 33. Connecticut (18) 34. Texas AM (17) 
35-tie Ariz. State (13.5) 43-tie Florida State (7) 43-tie Purdue (7) 
43-tie Colorado (7) 46-tie Georgia (4.5) 48-tie Rutgers (2.5)
50. Nebraska (0.5)

Economics
5. Stanford (46) 6-tie California ( 44.5) 8. Northwestern (43) 
10-tie Minnesota (41) 12-tie Michigan (39) 14-tie UCLA (36.5) 
14-tie Wisconsin (36.5) 19. Duke (32) 22-tie Maryland (28.5) 
25-tie Texas (25.5) 27. Penn State (27) 28-tie Ohio State (22)
28-tie Virginia (22) 31-tie Boston College (19) 31-tie Mich. State (31) 
31-tie Illinois (31) 34-tie Iowa (15.5)34-tie North Carol. (15.5) 
34-tie Washington (15.5) 34-tie Vanderbilt (15.5) 39-tie Ariz. State (11)
39-tie Arizona (11) 39-tie Pitt (11) 42-tie Purdue (7.5) 
42-tie Texas AM (7.5)  46-tie Indiana (4.5) 48-tie Florida (2.5) 
50-tie North Car. State (.3)  50-tie Rutgers (.3) 50-tie Colorado (.3) 
50-tie USC (.3)

Sociology
1. California (50) 2. Wisconsin (49) 3-tie Michigan (47.5) 
5-tie Stanford (44.5) 5-tie North Carol (44.5) 
9-tie Northwestern (41.5)  9-tie UCLA (41.5) 11-tie Indiana (39) 14-tie Duke (36) 14-tie Texas (36) 17-tie Ohio State (33) 
17-tie Washington (33) 20-tie Penn State (29) 20-tie Arizona (29) 
20-tie Maryland (29) 20-tie Minnesota (29) 31-tie Rutgers (18) 
31-tie Vanderbilt (18) 36-tie Iowa (14) 36-tie Virginia (14) 
39-tie Florida State (11.5) 39-tie USC (11.5) 
41-tie Boston College (7) 41-tie Texas AM (7) 41-tie Florida (7) 
41-tie Wash. State (7) 48-tie Mich. State (1) 
48-tie North Carol. State (1) 48-tie Georgia (1) 48-tie Illinois (1) 
48-tie Notre Dame (1)

Public Affairs
1. Syracuse (50) 2-tie Indiana (48.5) 4-tie Georgia 46.5 
6. California (45) 7-tie Kansas (43) 7-tie Michigan (43) 
7-tie USC 43 10-tie Duke (39.5) 14-tie UCLA (32) 
14-tie Minnesota (32) 14-tie North Carol. (32) 14-tie Texas (32) 
14-tie Washington (32) 14-tie Wisconsin (32) 
25-tie Ariz. State (25.5) 25-tie Maryland (25.5) 
27-tie Florida State (22) 27-tie Pitt (22) 27-tie Virginia Tech (22) 
32-tie Kentucky (17.5) 36-tie Ohio State (13) 36-tie Texas AM (13) 
36-tie Arizona (13) 36-tie Missouri (13)

History
1-tie Stanford (48.5) 1-tie California (48.5) 7-tie Michigan (43.5) 
9-tie UCLA (41) 12-tie North. Carol (38.5) 14-tie Duke (36) 
14-tie Northwestern (36) 14-tie Wisconsin (36) 17-tie Texas (33) 
20-tie Rutgers (30.5) 20-tie Virginia (30.5) 22-tie Indiana (28.5) 
22-tie Illinois (28.5) 24-tie Minnesota (26.5) 24-tie Ohio State (26.5)
26-tie Washington (24.5) 26-tie Vanderbilt (24.5) 33-tie Maryland (17) 
36-tie Iowa (12.5) 36-tie Notre Dame (12.5) 42-tie Pitt (6.5) 
42-tie USC (6.5) 42-tie Arizona (6.5) 48-tie Florida (1.5) 
48-tie Penn State (1.5)

Psychology
1-tie Stanford (44.5) 1-tie California (44.5) 3-tie UCLA (46.5) 
3-tie Michigan (46.5) 7. Illinois (44)8-tie Minnesota (42) 
8-tie Wisconsin (42) 13-tie North Carol. (36.5) 13-tie Texas AM (36.5)
13-tie Washington (36.5) 17-tie Northwestern (31.5) 
17-tie Ohio State (31.5) 23-tie Indiana (25.5)23-tie Duke (25.5) 
23-tie Virginia (25.5) 29-tie Penn State (19) 29-tie Colorado (19) 
29-tie Iowa (19) 29-tie Vanderbilt (19) 36-tie Ariz. State (13.5) 
36-tie Oregon (13.5) 36-tie Pitt (13.5) 40-tie Arizona (8.5) 
40-tie Kansas (8.5) 40-tie Maryland (8.5) 40-tie USC (8.5) 
45-tie Purdue (4) 45-tie Mich. State (4) 45-tie Florida (4) 
45-tie Missouri (4) 50-tie Florida State (0.1) 50-tie Connecticut (0.1) 
50-tie Georgia (0.1)

Fine Arts
7-tie UCLA (43) 15-tie Texas (33.5) 21-tie Ohio State (26) 
21-tie Illinois (26) 21-tie Iowa (26) 21-tie Wisconsin (26) 
30-tie Ariz. State (18) 30-tie Indiana (18) 30-tie Rutgers (18) 
37-tie California (10.5) 37-tie Georgia (10.5) 37-tie Michigan (10.5) 
37-tie USC (10.5) 37-tie Washington (10.5) 45-tie Stanford (4)
45-tie Arizona (4) 45-tie Cincinnati (4) 50-tie Penn State (0.1) 
50-tie Syracuse (0.1) 50-tie Minnesota (0.1) 50-tie Tennessee (0.1)

Physics
1-tie Stanford (48.5) 5-tie California (45.5) 9. Illinois (42) 
11-tie Michigan (39) 14-tie Texas (36) 14-tie Maryland (36) 
17-tie Wisconsin (33.5) 19-tie UCLA (30.5) 19-tie Colorado (30.5)
19-tie Washington (30.5) 23-tie Ohio State (27) 23-tie Penn State (27) 
26-tie Minnesota (23.5) 26-tie Rutgers (23.5) 30-tie Duke (18.5) 
30-tie Georgia Tech (18.5) 30-tie Northwestern (18.5)
36-tie Mich. State (13.5) 36-tie Florida (13.5) 36-tie North Carol. (13.5) 
36-tie Arizona (13.5) 40-tie Indiana (7.5) 40-tie Purdue (7.5) 
40-tie Texas AM (7.5) 40-tie Virginia (7.5) 48-tie Ariz. State (1.5)
48-tie Florida State (1.5) 48-tie Iowa State (1.5)

Biological Sciences
1. Stanford (50) 2-tie California (48) 13-tie Duke (37.5) 
15-tie Washington (34) 15-tie Wisconsin (34)
20-tie Michigan (29.5) 24-tie UCLA (26.5) 
24-tie North Carol. (26.5) 26-tie Baylor (23.5) 
26-tie Northwestern (23.5) 26-tie Texas (23.5) 
30-tie Colorado (20.5) 30-tie Illinois (20.5) 32-tie Minnesota (18.5) 
32-tie Vanderbilt (18.5) 34-tie Indiana (13.5)  34-tie Arizona (13.5) 
42-tie Penn State (7.5) 46-tie Mich. State (1.5) 
46-tie Ohio State (1.5) 46-tie Florida (1.5) 46-tie Georgia (1.5) 
46-tie Pitt (1.5) 46-tie USC (1.5) 46-tie Virginia (1.5)

Chemistry
1-tie California (49) 4-tie Stanford (46.5) 6. Illinois (45) 
7-tie Northwestern (43)7-tie Wisconsin (43) 12. Texas (39) 
13-tie North Carol. (37) 16-tie UCLA (34) 16-tie Michigan (34) 
19-tie Texas AM (31.5) 21-tie Minnesota (27.5) 
21-tie Purdue (27.5) 21-tie Penn State (27.5) 
21-tie Georgia Tech (27.5) 26-tie Colorado (23.5)
26-tie Ohio State (23.5) 26-tie Washington (23.5) 36. Florida (15) 
37. Utah (14) 38-tie Mich. State (10) 38-tie Pitt (10)
38-tie Iowa State (10) 38-tie Arizona (10) 38-tie Maryland (10) 
45-tie Duke (4.5) 45-tie Virginia (4.5) 45-tie Boston College (4.5) 
49-tie Vanderbilt (0.8)

English
1. California (50) 2-tie Stanford (48.5) 10-tie Duke (40) 
10-tie UCLA (40) 10-tie Virginia (40) 13-tie Michigan (37) 
16. North Carol. (35) 17-tie Rutgers (33) 17-tie Texas (33)
17-tie Wisconsin (33) 20-tie Northwestern (30.5) 
22-tie Indiana (27.5) 22-tie Illinois (27.5) 26-tie Ohio State (24) 
29-tie Penn State (19.5) 29-tie Iowa (19.5) 
29-tie Washington (19.5) 29-tie Vanderbilt (19.5) 
35-tie Minnesota (15) 35-tie Maryland (15) 35-tie Pitt (15) 
38-tie USC (12) 46-tie Colorado (2.5) 46-tie Notre Dame (2.5)

Math
2-tie Stanford (47.5) 2-tie California (47.5) 8-tie UCLA (42.5) 
8-tie Michigan (42.5) 14-tie Texas (36.5) 16-tie Northwestern (34.5) 
16-tie Wisconsin (34.5) 18-tie Minnesota (32.5) 20-tie Rutgers (29.5)
20-tie Illinois (29.5) 20-tie Maryland (29.5) 24-tie Duke (26) 
27-tie Penn State (23) 27-tie Purdue (23) 27-tie Washington (23) 
30-tie Georgia Tech (18.5) 30-tie Indiana (18.5) 30-tie Ohio State (18.5)
30-tie North Carol. (18.5) 30-tie Utah (18.5) 40-tie Texas AM (10) 
43-tie Arizona (7) 43-tie Mich. State (7) 46-tie Colorado (3) 
46-tie Notre Dame (3) 46-tie Virginia (3)

Engineering
1. Stanford (49) 3. California (48) 4. Georgia Tech (47) 
5. Illinois (46) 8. Texas (43) 9. Michigan (42)
11-tie Purdue (39.5) 11-tie USC (39.5) 13. Texas AM (38) 
14-tie UCLA (36.5) 16-tie Wisconsin (34.5) 20. Northwestern (31) 
22. Maryland (29) 24. Virginia Tech (27) 25. Penn State (26)
27-tie Minnesota (23.5) 27-tie Washington (23.5) 
29. Ohio State (22) 30. Florida (21) 31-tie Duke (19) 
31-tie North Carol. State (19) 36. Colorado (15) 
37-tie Vanderbilt (13.5) 39-tie Virginia (11) 44. Ariz. State (7) 
45-tie Iowa State (5.5) 50-tie Arizona (0.5)


http://grad-schools.usnews.rankingsandreviews.com/best-graduate-schools 
                 Link to US News Graduate School Rankings






Which BCS Schools/Conferences Are Committed To Academic Excellence? (Part 1)

Every fall I watch a vast number of college football games. At halftime each of the competing schools have an advertisement, usually a student with goggles and looking at a test tube, in which the university president proclaims the academic excellence of that school. Most of us know many of those “ads” are purely BS and nothing but propaganda. Not saying particular schools don't have decent academic credentials, but to say they are “world class” is a monumental stretch. I did a bit of research to discover which Bowl Championship Series conferences and universities put as much value into their academic programs as they put into their athletic programs. Which of the football powerhouses have a commitment to academics and which ones truly rank as “world class”.

How I ranked the schools

I used the rankings from US NEWS 2012 rankings for this nation's top graduate programs as my data source. I chose to use the graduate school rankings instead of undergrad rankings because the undergrad rankings have nothing to do with a genuine commitment of resources toward academic programs.

For a university to achieve a top undergraduate ranking the school needs to have a small enrollment (that means a low student to teacher ration), have students pay enormous tuition, and set exceedingly high entrance standards. It also helps to have a good academic reputation that spans 100 years or more. The student's produced will be quality students but they came into the university as a quality student. Large state universities will never have a high ranking. State universities with a mandate to educate the masses is another barrier to achieving a high undergrad ranking. The top 10 ranked universities for undergrads have an average enrollment of 5,711 students with an average tuition of $39,280.

A university's graduate programs reveal their commitment of resources towards education. You will find that the schools having the higher ranked graduate programs spend a lot of money on each and every student that is enrolled in the program. Great grad programs have highly respected professors that require greater than average salaries to hire and keep them. Quality graduate programs demand excellent facilities for study and research.  Highly ranked grad programs also require a commitment of money for sending students to national and world-wide conferences and workshops.

To emphasize my reasons for using grad programs as the measure of academic commitment, I will compare a few universities undergrad rankings to their grad rankings. University of Notre Dame (8,372 students, tuition $39,919) has a national undergrad ranking of #17 but does not crack the top 30 in my BCS grad school rankings. Wake Forest (4,569 students, tuition $39,970) has an undergrad ranking of #25 but is near the bottom of all BCS schools in graduate program rankings. Highly regarded state universities for excellence in their graduate programs include Michigan, Washington, Texas, and Wisconsin. Their respective undergrad rankings by USNEWS were #25, #41, #45, and #45. University of Miami (a private school) scored 0 pts in my graduate school rankings but in the undergrad rankings Miami was ranked higher than Illinois, Penn State, and Minnesota (large state universities). These Big 10 schools have great grad school programs and their national graduate program rankings reveal it. The primary reason that the aforementioned Big 10 schools were ranked so low on the undergraduate scale is because of their high enrollment numbers.

I selected 15 varied graduate programs in which to rank the universities (Business, Political Science, Education, Economics, History, Psychology, Sociology, Public Affairs, Biological Sciences, Chemistry, Physics, Fine Arts, English, Math, and Engineering). To receive points, the university had to rank in the nations Top 50 schools for that particular program. I scored each school in the way one would score a cross country meet. #1 rank = 50 pts , #2 rank = 49 pts, ...., #50 rank = 1 pt and 0 pts for a school if they were not listed in the Top 50 for that particular program.

The BCS (Bowl Championship Series) schools are found in 6 conferences (Big 10, Pac12, ACC, SEC, Big East, and Big 12). I also included independents Notre Dame and BYU in the rankings. 69 schools were in this evaluation process.

CONFERENCE RANKINGS
      
Rank - University- Total Points- # of times ranked in the top 50

Big10 (264.7 average)

1. Michigan             578.8         15/15
2. Wisconsin          491             15/15
3. Northwestern     451.5         13/15
4. Illinois                 398            14/15
5. Minnesota           396.6         15/15
6. Ohio State          358             15/15
7. Indiana                313.5          13/15
8. Penn State         260.6           14/15
9. Iowa                     155                9/15
10. Mich. State      113              10/15
11. Purdue             111.5             8/15 
12. Nebraska             0.5             1/15


Pac12 (242.2 average)

1. California         663                15/15
2. Stanford            628                14/15
3. UCLA                572                15/15
4. Washington     385                15/15
5. USC                   199.8             11/15
6. Colorado           127.2             10/15
7. Arizona             121                12/15
8. Arizona State   114                  8/15
9. Oregon                56.5               2/15
10. Utah                   32.5               2/15
11. Wash. State        7                  1/15
12. Oregon State      0                 0/15

ACC (137.2 average)

1. Duke                   395               13/15
2. North Carolina 387.5             13/15
3. Maryland           282.5            13/15
4. Virginia              244               13/15
5. Georgia Tech    133                 5/15
6. Boston College   83                 5/15
7. Virg. Tech           49                 2/15
8. Florida State      48                 6/15
9. N.Carol.State     20.3              3/15
10. Wake Forest      3.5              1/15
11. Miami (Fla)        0                 0/15
11. Clemson              0                 0/15


Big12 (83.7 average)

1. Texas                519                15/15
2. Texas A&M    176.5             10/15
3. Kansas               84                  3/15
4. Baylor                23.5               1/15
5. Iowa State         17                  3/15
5. Missouri             17                  2/15
7. Kansas State      0                  0/15
7. Oklahoma           0                  0/15
7. Okla. State         0                  0/15
7. Texas Tech         0                  0/15


Big East (34.8 average)

1. Rutgers              128.3             8/15
2. Pittsburgh         112.4             9/15
3. Syracuse              50.1             2/15
4. Connecticut        18.1             2/15
5. Cincinnati             4                 1/15
6. Texas Christian    0                 0/15
6. West Virginia       0                 0/15
6. South Florida       0                 0/15
6. Louisville              0                 0/15

SEC (29.8 average) 

1. Vanderbilt         206.7           11/15
2. Florida                 69.5             9/15
3. Georgia               64.1             6/15
4. Kentucky            17.5             1/15
5. Tennessee              0.1            1/15
6. Alabama                0               0/15
6. Auburn                   0               0/15
6. Arkansas                0               0/15
6. LSU                        0               0/15
6. Mississippi             0                0/15
6. Miss. State            0                0/15
6. South Carolina    0                0/15 

Independents 

1. Notre Dame          46                6/15
2. Brigham Young    18.5            1/15  


Mike's summary: Kudo's to the Big10. That conference has tremendous depth in the quality of their academic programs. Nebraska may be able to compete on the football field, but doesn't offer much to the conference in academic standing.  The Pac12 is obviously top heavy, but eight of that conference's schools are in the Top 30 (see next page). University of Texas might have the best overall athletic program in the nation and their academics follow suit. No wonder the other Big12 schools sacrifice their own revenues to keep Texas from leaving the Big12. The SEC is known as the top football conference in the nation. You can tell a person's or organization's priorities by looking at their checkbook. Easy to see the most important priority in SEC country, and it is not academic excellence.

Top 30 Ranked BCS Universities
 

  1. Cal-Berkeley (663)
  2. Stanford (628)
  3. Michigan (578.5)
  4. UCLA (572)
  5. Texas (519)
  6. Wisconsin (491)
  7. Northwestern (451.5)
  8. Illinois (398)
  9. Minnesota (396.6)
  10. Duke (395)
  11. North Carolina (387.5)
  12. Washington (385)
  13. Ohio State (358)
  14. Indiana (313)
  15. Maryland (282.5)
  16. Penn State (260.6)
  17. Virginia (244)
  18. Vanderbilt (206.7)
  19. USC (199.8)
  20. Texas A&M (176.5)
  21. Iowa (155)
  22. Georgia Tech (133)
  23. Rutgers (128.3)
  24. Colorado (127.2)
  25. Arizona (121)
  26. Arizona State (114)
  27. Michigan State (113)
  28. Pittsburgh (112.4)
  29. Purdue (111.5)
  30. Kansas (84)


    (Check out Part 2 to see how the schools ranked in each of the 15 academic programs)



Saturday, April 2, 2011

Minneapolis/St.Paul 2010 (part 2)

THE UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA

                       http://fightmusic.com/big10.html


The University of Minnesota is a large city university, large enrollment, and has school colors of maroon and gold (sound familiar to any of you).  The UofM is a historic campus with loads of tradition and carries a great academic reputation (as do all of the Big10 schools with the exception of Nebraska).

    note:  see my next blog regarding rating the BCS football conferences and teams according to academic excellence.

Another charming feature of the UofM campus is the Mississippi River.  The river divides the university into the East Campus and the West Campus.  After 4 years you would expect David to love the place or despise it.  He loves it and would love nothing more than to get a professorship in one of the many colleges and universities located in Minneapolis and St. Paul.

http://www.laughstub.com/images/venues/umin.jpg


http://www.bookstores.umn.edu/images/system/category/1653.jpg

http://images.forbes.com/media/lists/94/2009/university-of-minnesota-twin-cities.jpg
http://www.eduinreview.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/mn.jpg
Political Science building and David's office is to the left of the bridge (West Campus)

I'd be remiss not to give kudo's to the UofM's Department of Political Science.  Upon graduation from ASU, David and his advisors were discussing possible grad school destinations.  A professor or two entered into the discussion and suggested that UofMinn would be the perfect fit for David.  Up to that moment, UofMinn was never on our radar.  Upon further research, we found that their department was highly ranked on the national level and just as important their funding for students was greater than the other universities under consideration.

The university and faculty of the Poli-Sci department have pushed David to heights that are beyond his natural capabilities.  In many ways, they are putting him through a 'green beret' type of academic experience.  For example, his final dissertation will be in the form of a published book.  Because he is not finished with all his research as he approaches completion of his fifth year, the university has continued his funding for a sixth year as they want him to finish that book.  The Hubert Humphrey Department of Public Policy came through with a very generous fellowship for David.

As a parent, I'm grateful that UofMinn is pushing my son to levels none of us would ever imagine and helping him achieve his goals along the way.




 








David's first published piece.  Chapter 24 of this book.

 David's office.  A grandson having an office can really blow a grandmother's mind!









Friday, April 1, 2011

Minneapolis/St.Paul 2010 (part 1)

                                Minneapolis Skyline


During the last week of May in 2010, Bonnie and I took Grandma (mom to some and G-G to others) to visit David.  At that time David had finished his fourth year of grad-school at the University of Minnesota.

Having visited Minnepolis/St.Paul three times, Bonnie and I agree that it is a fun and progressive city loaded with midwestern charm.
In spite of the winters, David has stated on many occasions that he loves living there and wouldn't mind his first job to be located in the Twin Cities area.  Great place for the human carnivores (great hamburgers and steak).

Minneapolis has some great parks, particularly one that surrounds 3 to 4 lakes known as the Chain of Lakes.  What a great running path that surrounds the lakes!

Beach area was well attended on this warm May afternoon

David and Mike take a break (my back was killing me on this trip, was to receive diagnosis the week we returned to Phoenix)
David and Grandma take another break from the hike along the path surrounding the lakes.
 One of the more captivating natural resources in Minneapolis is the Mississippi River.  The river actually has it commercial beginnings in Minneapolis.

Davy gives the river a passing mark
Something captivating about a river that flows through town

Pat, son, and grandson at rivers edge

One of several locks and dams along the Minneapolis portion of the river.  Closer to town I witnessed a barge being lowered from a higher elevation to a lower elevation of the Mississippi River.

 Pat (Grandma) is a huge baseball fan.  Having grown up in St. Louis she developed her love of baseball and her love of the Mississippi River.

We were fortunate to be able to catch a game between the Twins and the hated Yankees.  Of course the Twins won this regular season game and then went on to be swept (again) by the Yankees in the playoffs.

Cuddyer hit two homeruns for the Twins and J. Maurer picked up two more fans in Bonnie and Pat.
Can you say "over paid" ?

If you ever trip to downtown Minneapolis, let me recommend to you the Normandy Inn.  It's part of the Best Western Chain.  Easy parking access.  Comfortable and quiet.  Within walking distance to everything.  Every evening they serve 'milk and cookies' for the guests.