GLOSSARY:
"taqiyya" - an Arab word that literally means concealing, precaution, guarding. It is employed to disguise one's beliefs, intentions, convictions, ideas, feelings, opinions, or strategies. In practical terms it is manifested as dissimulation, lying, deceiving, vexing and confounding with the intention of deflecting attention, foiling or pre-emptive blocking. It is currently employed in fending off and neutralizing any criticism of Islam or Muslims.
"Palestine" - originated from the Greek word pronounced Palaistina, which is derived from the Hebrew word pronounced pel-eh-sheth, meaning the land of the Philistines (one of the most famous of whom was Goliath). The Philistines were the arch-enemies of the Israelites from the period of the OT judges up to the reign of King David. The Philistines were of Aegean or Cypriot origins (not of Arab origins). They dwelt in the parcel of land now known as Gaza. Palestine was a regional name that was imposed on the area by the Roman Emperor, Hadrian, who suppressed the Second Jewish Revolt in AD 135. He was so angry with the Jews that he wanted to humiliate them and emphasize that the Jewish nation had lost its right to a homeland under Roman rule.
The truth is that a state of Palestine has never existed. The people claiming to be Palestinian refugees were actually migrant workers that entered Israel for work. They came after Israel was established and they were provided a better income and quality of life, in this once wasteland. Until 1930 the word Palestine was always used to describe Jews by the European nations. Prior to the emergence of Yasar Arafat, these migrants preferred to be called Southern Syrians. Only when Arafat declared his nationality as Palestinian, did this term and definition become popular with Arab nations and people.
"Hamas"- an acronym of Harakat al-Muqawamat al-Islamiyyah that means Islamic Resistance Movement. It is the political party that now governs the Gaza Strip. Since June 2007 Hamas has played a major role in the governance of the Gaza portion of the Palestinian Territories, after it won a majority of seats in the Palestinian Parliament in January 2006.
Regardless of the Arab Muslim's hatred and disapproval of Israel's existence in the Middle East, and their desire to seek the destruction of Israel, Israel has a historical, legal, and moral right to exist as a Jewish state.
My argument will not address this topic from a Biblical perspective. I could reference over 100 verses in the Bible that would support Israel's position, but that would be "preaching to the choir." Most people that maintain the Palestinian's right to the Holy Land don't believe the accuracy or relevancy of the Bible, therefore to use it as the foundation of my argument would be fruitless. Recent survey's have also shown that 70% to 80% of Israeli Jews are non-religious, therefore the path best taken would be through the historical and the archeological record.
According to the Arab-Palestinian-Muslim narrative, Israel is an alien colony that was recently planted into the Arab world by American and European imperialism. This narrative does not recognize history prior to the arrival of the first Zionist pioneers in the 1880's and emphatically denies any ancient historical connection of the Jewish people to the land of Israel. They want people to believe that the word "Israel" was invented in modern times. Palestinian Arab schools and textbooks now teach students, "Palestine was ended with a catatstrophe that is unprecedented in history, when the Zionist gangs stole Palestine and expelled its people from their cities, their villages, their lands, and their homes in order to establish the state of Israel."
According to a well-known hieroglyphic inscription, the tribes of Israel were a significant, established presence in Canaan no later than 1212 BC. There is a vast body of archaeological evidence that demonstrates the ancient Israelite/Jewish presence in Israel/Judea as far back as 925 BC. This historical presence is verified in the ancient records of the Egyptian, Assyrian, Babylonian, Persian, Greek, Roman, Byzantine, and even Muslim empires. The Arab conquest of the "Holy Land" did not occur until AD 638. An exercise in basic arithmetic reveals that the Jewish people were there over 18 centuries before the arrival of the Arabs. Despite being conquered many times, the Jewish people have a constant and uninterrupted presence in the land of Israel for over 30 centuries. It has conveniently been forgotten that the Jews and New Testament Christians were there before any Arab presence.
In the 30 centuries preceding the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948, there have been only two periods when there was an independent, internationally recognized state in the area that now comprises Israel. Both of them were Jewish states (Kingdoms of Judea and Israel). Even when the land was part of the Arab Empire (AD 638 through AD 1099), there was never an independent Arab state in "Palestine", by that name or any other. No wonder the Arabs are donating millions of dollars to U.S. colleges for Middle Eastern schools of study. They have a lot of hard historical evidence to rewrite in the young minds of students.
Finally, the Jewish people have a distinct national identity. Religion is only one of the unique characteristics that define this national identity. The Jewish people have a separate and distinct language, culture, and customs along with a documented history of development over the past 3,000 years. The Jewish people have created a vast body of art and literature, both secular and religious, which reflects the connection of the Jewish people to the land of Israel. The Dead Sea Scrolls, written when the descendants of the Maccabees ruled an independent Judea, demonstrate that the Jewish people, both in the Holy Land and in exile all over the world, have been reading and writing secular and sectarian literature in the same distinct language for over 2,000 years. Jews consider Jerusalem to be their most holy site.
In contrast, the Arabic language and culture and the Muslim religion of the Palestinians are essentially indistinguishable from those of the wider Arab world. Prior to the 1800's there is not a trace of a unique Palestinian art, literature, music, or any other manifestation of a distinct culture. I dare you to find one Palestinian book, author, or artist from the year 1300 through the year 1800. Ask a Columbia University professor of Middle Eastern history or a Palestinian nationalist to name one, and the most honest answer you could receive would be silence. Most likely, the response would be "taqiyya". In reading the Jewish sacred writings of antiquity, one would find Jerusalem mentioned at least 767 times. Islam considers Jerusalem to be its third most holy site. The Koran does not mention Jerusalem even one time.
Any objective observer would conclude from the facts that the claim of the Jewish people to national identity and sovereignty in Israel is much stronger than that of the Palestinians.
WHO ARE THE PALESTINIAN REFUGEES?
Between 1517 and 1917, the Ottoman Empire of Turkey controlled the areas of Lebanon, Syria, and the region known as Palestine. Supporting Germany during WWI, the Turks were defeated and in 1916 the southern portion of control was mandated to Britain and France. Lebanon and Syria going to France and Palestine (areas known today as Israel, Jordan, and the West Bank) controlled by the British. The Jews had already began their mass migration to Palestine in the 1880's and had started changing the vast wasteland into fertile and bountiful farm land. This attracted a large number of Arab immigrants who were looking for employment and better living conditions. The reason it was so desolate was because no other countries or peoples had ever claimed Palestine for its own and thus no one took proper care of the land or attempted to cultivate it to its true potential. When the land started to flourish and prosper due to the efforts of the Jewish settlers, other peoples (including Arabs) saw this and began to migrate into this land.
With continuous attacks on Jewish settlements, Arab Palestinians (most of whom immigrated from other Arab lands) began a systematic effort to drive out the Jews from the area west of the Jordan River. Most widely known was the 1936-39 Arab Revolt, where attacks on Jews continued mercilessly. This was a revolt against British colonial rule and Jewish immigration.
By 1947, the British had grown weary of the Middle East and left it to the United Nations to decide the fate of the region. On May 14, 1948 the Palestinian Jews celebrated for the first time as citizens of Israel. The very next day, seven neighboring Arab armies of Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, and Yemen invaded the new state. Many Arabs who were living within the new Israeli boundaries were encouraged to leave by the other Arab states so a mass invasion could wipe out all of the Jews. The Arabs, anticipating an easy victory, promised Jewish land and property in return. This war lasted about a year and a half and the Arabs that stayed within Israeli boundaries were given Israeli citizenship. Those who left are known as the first wave of refugees. The refugees that fled to Arab nations were herded into prison like camps. They were never offered citizenship, never granted rights by their Muslim hosts, and never assimilated into the fabric of the societies of Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, or Egypt.
The second wave of refugees came as a result of the 6-Day War of 1967. As Arab nations around Israel prepared for their military offensive, Palestinian Arabs again fled to Lebanon and Jordan with the expectation of returning when Israel was defeated and destroyed. Their expectations were once again crushed.
A third wave was actually the consequence of Black September in Jordan (September 1970). King Hussein grew weary of all the agitating by the PLO (refugees) as it was very destabilizing to his country. He ordered the expulsion of the PLO and killed thousands of PLO gunmen and Palestinian civilians in the process. The third wave of refugees migrated primarily to Lebanon, which essentially destroyed that once modern, prosperous, multi-cultural and diverse nation.
Despite the fact that the Muslim nations surrounding Israel are 650 times the size of this tiny state, they made no effort to absorb the approximately 600,000 Arab refugees who fled Israel in 1948 when war was declared on Israel by five neighboring Arab nations. To this day, these refugees are not welcomed by other Arab states. As expressed more than 20 years ago by Ralph Galloway, former head of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian Refugees, “The Arab States do want to solve the refugee problem. They want to keep it as an open sore, as an affront to the United Nations and as a weapon against Israel.” Yet Israel absorbed roughly 800,000 Jewish refugees that had to flee from Muslim nations after 1948.
IS PEACE IN THE MIDDLE EAST A VIABLE POSSIBILITY?
I find ludicrous the thought that Israel will be perfectly secure surrounded by the Arab horde intent on driving Israel off the map. Politicians and voters seem to believe that enough money and political will makes anything a possibility. Some things are not possible and peace in the Middle East is one of them. (I will have another blog in a couple of weeks that will explain my position from a Biblical perspective)
Contrary to popular world opinion, Israel does not deny Palestinian national rights. The State of Israel has accepted in good faith or initiated every proposal for a genuine "two-state solution" that has ever been introduced. In contrast, the Arab world, Palestinian nationalists, and radical Islamists have consistently denied Israels right to exist, and they have responded to every settlement proposal with extreme violence. The missed opportunities for peace include the 1937 Peel Commission Proposal, the 1947 UN Partition Plan, UN Security Council Resolution 242 in 1967, and the proposals made by Israel at Camp David in 2000.
More importantly and relevant for today, current Palestinian nationalist leadership says it will accept a "two-state solution" being conditioned on an unlimited "right of return" for Palestinian refugees. According to this "right of return" proposal, about 5 million Palestinian refugees will have the right to live within Israel's pre-1967 borders which would immediately bring minority status to the Israeli Jews. This current strategy of the so called moderate Palestinians is to destroy Israel by demographic rather than military means. In a June 2003 Pew Research poll, 80% of Palestinians said their rights and needs can never be met as long as Israel exists. With Hamas given more input (2006 Parliament elections) in Palestinian affairs, it remains clear that Palestinians will not be content until Israel and its Jewish citizens are wiped completely off the map. As Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu suggested to President Obama, "asking Israel to negotiate with Hamas is like asking the United States to negotiate with al-Queda."
MAPS
Map of Israel Today
Canaan (1400 - 1100 BC)
Updated information regarding "Old Jerusalem" of 2000 years ago:
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/ml_israel_underground_jerusalem
![]() |























