THE MYTH OF THE CLINTON/GINGRICH SURPLUS
Time and time again, we read and hear of the claim that the federal budget was balanced and had a surplus during the reign of the of Bill Clinton presidency and the Newt Gingrich led Congress. Hey, I even believed it because the declaration has been so bipartisan in its support.
In actuality, there was never a surplus and the facts support this position. All numbers can be verified by accessing the U.S. Treasury website where the national debt is updated daily and a history of the debt since January 1993 can be obtained.
http://www.treasurydirect.gov/NP/BPDLogin?application=np
The claim is made that in FY 1998 the nation had a surplus of $69 billion. The claim also states that FY's 1999 and 2000 boasted surpluses of $123 billion and $230 million. The fact is that the national debt in FY's 1998 to 2000 increased by $281 billion.
Fiscal
Year | Year
Ending | National Debt | Deficit |
| FY1993 | 09/30/1993 | $4.411488 trillion | |
| FY1994 | 09/30/1994 | $4.692749 trillion | $281.26 billion |
| FY1995 | 09/29/1995 | $4.973982 trillion | $281.23 billion |
| FY1996 | 09/30/1996 | $5.224810 trillion | $250.83 billion |
| FY1997 | 09/30/1997 | $5.413146 trillion | $188.34 billion |
| FY1998 | 09/30/1998 | $5.526193 trillion | $113.05 billion |
| FY1999 | 09/30/1999 | $5.656270 trillion | $130.08 billion |
| FY2000 | 09/29/2000 | $5.674178 trillion | $17.91 billion |
| FY2001 | 09/28/2001 | $5.807463 trillion | $133.29 billion |
As one can clearly see, in no year did the national debt go down, and Clinton/Gingrich did not leave Bush with a surplus. President Bush took office in January of 2001 and his first budget took effect October 1, 2001 for FY 2002. Therefore the $133.29 billiion dollar deficit in the year ending 9/28/2001 actually belonged to the Clinton administration.
So, what kind of smoke and mirrors is used to show a surplus? It has everything to do with Washington doublespeak and political smoke and mirrors.
Analyzing what happened requires the understanding the two concepts of what makes up the national debt. The national debt is made up of
public debt and
intra-governmental holdings.
The
public debt is debt held by the public, normally including things such as treasury bills, savings bonds, and other instruments the public can purchase from the government.
Intra-governmental holdings, on the other hand, occurs when the government borrows money from itself--mostly borrowing money from social security.
Looking at the makeup of the national debt and the claimed surpluses for the last 4 Clinton fiscal years, we have the following table:
Fiscal
Year | End
Date | Claimed
Surplus | Public
Debt | Intra-gov
Holdings | Total National
Debt |
| FY1997 | 09/30/1997 | | $3.789667T | $1.623478T | $5.413146T |
| FY1998 | 09/30/1998 | $69.2B | $3.733864T $55.8B | $1.792328T $168.9B | $5.526193T $113B |
| FY1999 | 09/30/1999 | $122.7B | $3.636104T $97.8B | $2.020166T $227.8B | $5.656270T $130.1B |
| FY2000 | 09/29/2000 | $230.0B | $3.405303T $230.8B | $2.268874T $248.7B | $5.674178T $17.9B |
| FY2001 | 09/28/2001 | | $3.339310T $66.0B | $2.468153T $199.3B | $5.807463T $133.3B |
Notice that while the
public debt went down in each of those four years, the
intra-governmental holdings went up each year by a far greater amount--and, in turn, the total
national debt (which is public debt + intra-governmental holdings) went up. Therein lies the discrepancy.
When it is claimed that Clinton paid down the national debt, that is patently false--as can be seen,
the national debt went up every single year. What fed's did do was to pay down the public
debt--notice that the claimed surplus is relatively close to the decrease in the public debt for those years. But they paid down the public debt by borrowing far
more money in the form of intra-governmental holdings (mostly Social Security).
A quote from an article on the CBS website:
"Over the past 25 years,
the government has gotten used to the fact that Social Security is providing free money to make the rest of the deficit look smaller," said Andrew Biggs, a resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute.
No laws were broken and interestingly, this most likely was not even a conscious decision by Clinton/Gingrich and their associates. The Social Security Administration is legally required to take all its surpluses and buy U.S. Government securities, and the U.S. Government readily sells those securities--which automatically and immediately becomes intragovernmental holdings. The economy was doing well due to the dot-com bubble and people were earning a lot of money and paying a lot into Social Security. Since Social Security had more money coming in than it had to pay in benefits to retired persons, all that extra money was immediately used to buy U.S. Government securities. The government was still running deficits, but since there was so much money coming from excess Social Security contributions there was no need to borrow more money directly from the public. As such, the public debt went down while intragovernmental holdings continued to skyrocket.
The net effect was that the national debt most definitely did
not get paid down because we did
not have a surplus. The government just covered its deficit by borrowing money from Social Security rather than the public. The treasury continues to treat trust fund deposits (such as Social Security) as revenues and uses them to generate false surpluses. If a private banker were to treat trust fund deposits as income and profit, that person would definitely face criminal charges.
Don't get caught up when politicians are boasting about a bill or piece of legislation that promises spending cuts. Nothing but lies, lies, and more lies. It is real simple to discern. Keep your eyes on the total national debt. If that figure continues to rise, spending is on the increase.
http://www.usdebtclock.org/index.html