The debate about the need for the reform of public pensions is not confined to the state of Arizona. It is a national problem. The Pew Center on the States released a study saying there is a $1 trillion ( that trillion word again) gap between what states have and what they need to fully fund their retirement plans. This report was actually released prior to the recent financial collapse. In year 2000, more than half the states had fully funded pensions. Today, no state has a fully funded public pension plan.
This debate is heated and sure to get hotter over the next several months. On one side there is the undeniable sense of entitlement among beneficiaries. From the other side, an undeniable sense of outrage at the six-figure payouts earned on the tab of taxpayers. I understand both sides of the debate and actually have one foot planted firmly on each side. I am a retired school teacher, fully vested in the Arizona State Retirement System. I knew the rules of the system and played by the rules as I planned my families financial future. Any major change to my benefits could prove catastrophic for me and other vested members. On the other foot, I am a taxpayer that has grown weary of the “smoke and mirrors” used by political leaders, bureaucrats, and administrators to game the system for their advantage at the expense of the taxpaying public.
The issue of pension reform is not much different than the issue of Social Security/Medicare reform at the national level. Most politicians and government leaders don't want to touch it with a 100 ft pole because of the emotions that arise. Whenever someone from either party dares to advocate common sense reform, the other side immediately demonizes them. Thus the discussion is tabled for another day. In my opinion, this state and this nation are out of “other days.” Why? That gray tsunami known as the Baby Boomer generation will soon overwhelm Social Security, Medicare, and state pensions. As 2011 opens, the first of the Baby Boomer generation will turn 65 at the rate of 10,000/day for the next 19 years. Combine that with the fact that in a little more than a century, Americans have gone from a life expectancy of 47 years to a life expectancy of 78 years. Soon the elders (of which I am one) will be more the problem than the problem-solvers.
Regarding this topic of pension reform, I will keep the focus on the state of Arizona. If the reader is a resident of any other state, I promise you that your state faces the same problems and may even be ahead of Arizona in bringing about the reform measures that I will be discussing. The other day I heard the results of a study that was done to measure the effect of an oncoming disaster on people that would be negatively influenced by that disaster situation. There was a dam about ready to collapse, thus ensuring massive floods in the region below the dam. The people completing the study wanted to evaluate the anxiety levels of a) the people living within 1 mile of the dam b) the people living within 2-3 miles of the dam and c) the people living within 4-5 miles of the dam. The people most concerned and most proactive in preparing for an upcoming disaster were those living farthest from the dam. The people living within 1 mile of the dam were less concerned, didn't feel preparations were needed, and hoped that it would all work itself out in a positive way. In other words, the closer we get to a crisis situation the more apt we are to just put our head in the sand and hope the problem will go away.
As a person living and depending on his public pension, I suggest a proactive approach to get this problem under control before the problem is totally out of control. I do know that the taxpaying public will no longer tolerate the support of a system that provides more generous benefits and much earlier retirement than they could ever receive.
What is the problem
Arizona has six different public pension systems. Arizona State Retirement System is the largest with over 220,000 active members. The number of retirees in this system increased by over 8,000 within the last couple of years to pass the 100,000 mark for the first time. The other, and much smaller pension systems cover policemen, firemen, elected officials, corrections officers and other government workers.
The problem is the tab for local governments and the state to run the six pension systems grew 448% over the past 10 years to $1.39 billion annually in benefits paid to retired public employees. Compare that total to the annual K-12 budget of $3.5 billion , $1.39 billion to the current Medicaid program, $949 million to Corrections, and $890 million to Universities. Therefore, a program that 10 years ago constituted a blip on the state's budgetary map now consumes more of Arizona's tax revenue than the entire state subsidy for higher education.
A more local example shows that the City of Peoria's pension costs for its employees rose from $1.8 million in 2001 to $8.4 million in 2010. These costs are paid out of the city's operating budget, taking 4% of the money that covers all day-to-day operations. Therefore, as pension costs grow other services must be cut. Cities and states don't share the luxury of our federal government and their ability to print money according to their whim and desires.
The current funding ratio of the 6 public pension plans range from 66% to 83%. The ASRS funding ration is at 75%. Industry standards state that a funding ratio above 80% is considered healthy, but of course having a trust at 100% funding is ideal. A funding ratio of 100% means the current value in the fund is equal to the cost calculated for all current and future retirees. Currently the ASRS is $8.7 billion underfunded and payments currently exceed contributions.
Typically, in good times, government replaces retiring employees with new workers contributing to the retirement system. With recent cuts to government budgets, those payrolls are shrinking. The real problem is that the number of retirees (remember the Baby Boomers) is growing at a much faster rate than those replacing them in the work force. The burden is then shifted to those still employed and their taxpayer-funded public employers.
Defined benefit pension plan vs 401(k)-type plan
In a defined benefit pension plan, an employer promises a specified monthly benefit on retirement that is predetermined by a formula based on the employee's earnings history, tenure of service, and age, rather than depending on investment returns.
In 1980, 84% of private-sector employee's had defined benefit plans. That number has now dropped to 21%. Recent records show that 84% of the state and local government workers still have defined benefit plans. Traditionally, public-employee pension systems were recognized as a way to overcome the inequities between lower payed public sector salaries and higher pay in the private sector. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the average Arizona state employee's salary in 2009 was $46,841, municipal employee average salary was $42,668, and in private industry the average pay was $42,090.
A dirty little secret (that I hesitate to share) of a phenomenal perk that comes with the defined benefit plan is found in the formula. Many retirees are not aware of this perk. If they were then they would never draw their retirement as a lump sum. When I retired, the formula allowed me to use my 3 highest consecutive annual salaries in computing my monthly benefit. My last statement from the ASRS included all my contributions + interest earned. With simple division, I found that I received the full contributed amount after 2.6 years of retirement. If you include the employer's contribution, then a full return of investment + interest would occur 5.2 years after retirement. That means all benefits after that are from “house money”. The number of years to receive a full return of the investment would have been less if I was drawing maximum monthly benefits. The plan I'm on designates my spouse as 100% beneficiary, thus the monthly amount is less. If I remember correctly, an economist stated that to receive this type of return from a 401(k) type plan would require an investment of over $1 million.
I believe the ASRS is now instituting a change in which the formula must include 5 consecutive years of annual salary. Honestly, I'm not sure that is enough. Real reform may require a more substantial change to the formula. Am I willing to give money back to the plan? Of course not! I played by the rules and planned accordingly. But I do know that the entire system could collapse if real reform is not instituted. If the entire system collapses, then we all lose.
A shift from the defined benefit plan to a 401(k) type plan is being proposed by governors in Alabama, Nevada, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Wisconsin, and Rhode Island. Alaska and Michigan have already adopted 401(k) type programs as their primary plan. For several reasons, I don't think we want to go there.
Double-Dipping
This may be the #1 hot-button item of today. This legal loophole allows senior employees to simultaneously retire and remain on the job without interruption. Double dipping poses a problem for several reasons. The most visible problem is the potential for abuse by administrators and bureaucratic leaders. Teachers and other rank and file employees take part in double-dipping programs, but the compensation they receive is cut and dry. That's due to the way that teachers salaries are determined. At the leadership levels, a lot of trickery can evolve due to favorable relationships that develop between administrators and school boards and the bureaucrats with their respective board of directors. These abuses are well documented on a near daily basis. Nothing seems to enrage the public more than the concept of double-dipping, especially when premeditated abuse is recognized.
I was fortunate to be able to double-dip for two years after retirement. I appreciated the extra income but never felt comfortable as I began to understand the consequences for the current teacher and the ASRS. When a retired employee returns to work, the employee and the employer no longer contribute to the pension plan. Investigators from the Arizona Republic estimate the practice of double-dipping is costing the ASRS trust at least $8.6 million in contributions per year. State wide, there are about 4,000 ASRS retirees that have returned to work.
The Deer Valley Unified School District (140 retirees) leads the state in the total number of double-dipping employees. The departing Superintendent of DVUSD had a combined income last year of nearly $300,000 and saved an additional $17,486 by not having to contribute to the ASRS. Of the 140 double-dippers, $3.7 million in pension was paid and $1.2 million was not paid to the ASRS.
All parties involved now agree that this system, as it now stands, must be reformed. The ASRS has proposed a plan to impose an “alternate contribution rate” for the employers if they hire an ASRS retiree. SmartSchoolsPlus is even endorsing this plan. Andrew Morrill, president of the Arizona Education Association wants to put a complete end to the program because of the pressure placed on the retirement system and the continual rise in employer and employee contributions.
The stress placed on current employees to save the system is near criminal, in my opinion. Employees and employers in the ASRS both contribute 9.6% of each employees yearly salary to the pension fund (total of 19.2%). That is cash out of the employees pocket. The employers have to draw from the fund that is used to hire and compensate staff. That figure will continue to rise upward to 12% over the next seven years. Next year will be the first time that the contribution rate will have reached double figures (10.5%).
During my last year of teaching I noticed that my pension contribution had increased dramatically. I never remembered that contribution grabbing my attention as it was at that time. When I got home from work I started pulling out check stubs from past years of employment. Sometime during the mid-2000's, I and other ASRS employees were contributing 2.2% to the system. Yes, the current employees are getting hammered, and it is going to get worse. Reform is needed.
The Arizona Constitution
At this moment, legislators and other officials are hamstrung to bring about substantial changes to the current pension system. In 1998, with a voter approval of 61%, Proposition 100 was passed. This constitutional amendment prohibited lawmakers from raiding any of the public-employer pension trusts for extra cash to balance the state budget. At that particular time the pension trusts had surpluses ranging from 14% to 21%. Prop 100 also mandated that public-employee pension benefits “shall not be diminished or impaired”. Arizona is now one of only nine states where participants in public pensions have a guaranteed right to a benefit that cannot be eliminated or diminished.
Speaker of the House Kirk Adams (Mesa): “It's time we get serious about reforming the public-pension systems. But if we are going to have any fundamental change, the voters will have to get involved.” His goal is to have the voters in 2012 change the State Constitution in order to remove the “shall not be diminished or impaired” clause.
Do you really want this going to the voters? I don't! Voters in 8 of 9 California cities and counties approved measures during the recent election to cut public-pension benefits. Thus, I'm in favor of getting ahead of the curve and bringing about reform that we can all live with. One change I'd propose would be to move all state pension plans to the ASRS. The ASRS is not without sin, but it seems that the smaller plans have the greater abuses. It's unbelievable how corrupt the managers of the smaller plans have been over the years, and it's gone unnoticed until uncovered in the last few months. More importantly, the smaller plans are not offering anything to reform their own system. For example, most of them are contributing less than 8% and balking when suggested that this rate should increase.
The ASRS has been proposing modest changes, but at least they are trying to avert an oncoming disaster. I suggest that all public employees live by the same rules when it comes to retirement. I would expect that oversight and management would be much simpler and effective when dealing with one pension plan.
State Bankruptcy
Currently U.S. states are not allowed to declare bankruptcy. There are many proponents of bankruptcy in this nation that would like to change the law. Cities and counties across the nation have already declared bankruptcy as a way to relieve their burdensome debt. In a bankruptcy court a judge could force lenders and public workers to accept less than what they are owed. Debt could drop overnight. Existing contracts could be replaced with cheaper ones. Thus far, state leaders across the nation are avoiding this particular option. Bankruptcy has not been seriously mentioned in this state as a means to solve our budget woes.
In my opinion, we (retirees and taxpayers) are headed for a train wreck if common sense reform is not instituted very soon. Once the Baby Boomer tsunami is fully vested into the retirement systems, reform will be too little and too late. My instinct tells me that “we can only resist gravity for only so long” and ultimately the fall will occur. We are entering into a ponzi-scheme scenario where the number of contributors will be outnumbered by the number of retirees. The only good news, from my perspective, is that the stock market doesn't seem to be significantly influenced by the woes on main street. Investment returns in 2009 were at an 18.28% loss but in 2010 the returns were at a 14.57% gain. We can sit and wait for the stock market to rise steadily over a period of a couple of years to get us out of this mess, but I'm not willing to count on that.
- I must give credit where credit is due. Last winter the Arizona Republic may have done their best job of investigative reporting in the history of that paper. Their reporters and investigators completed a multiple series of articles detailing their investigation of the state pension systems. The series of articles inspired me to write this particular piece and much of my data and information was gathered from their research and reporting. I encourage you to bookmark their site as it's a tremendous resource document. The articles reveal the many examples of blatant abuses to the system by those who should know better, that is the public servant placed in leadership positions.


