I continue the fight for them

I continue the fight for them
Daylen and Grandad at the beach

Monday, January 3, 2011

TWO PROGRAMS, TWO COACHES, AT THE CROSSROADS

Having been a more than casual observer of college football in the state of Arizona since 1963,  I'm not sure I have witnessed a season in which UofA and ASU  began the year with such dichotomous beginnings only to end up at the same place.  And that place is two coaches on the proverbial "hot seat".

Dick Tomey (former UofA Head Football Coach): "Win the kicking game, win the battle of turnovers, and you will win most of your ball games"

Never in a season has a recipe for winning been so prophetic.  During the first 8 games of the season, the Wildcats stormed through their games for a record of 7-1, thus earning a national ranking in the Top 15.  The wins included a 1 pt victory over the Cal Bears and a nationally televised 7 point win over Iowa of the Big 10.  The only blemish in that span was a 2 pt loss at home to the Oregon State Beavers.  For the most part, the Wildcats hit the big plays when needed, kept turnovers and penalties to a minimum, and the kicking game brought more positive than negatives.  I do remember reading comments from Wildcat fans during this streak that the kicking game was starting to show some cracks.  Not being a passionate observer of Wildcat football, I'm not quite sure what those cracks were, but one of my 'Cat relatives can probably clue us in.

Mike Stoops was the toast of the town.  He had brought UofA football to the next level (more commentary on this later).  Wildcat players would break each huddle with "1, 2, 3, Rose Bowl".

Up in Tempe, another catastrophe was in the works.  As a Sun Devil fan, last year was my first season in which I had ever experienced two losing seasons in a row.  It now appeared as Devil fans were going to have to accept 3 losing seasons in a row.  Having researched such trivial items such as this, USC-UCLA- and ASU are the only teams in the Pac10 to never have more than 2 losing seasons in a row.   The HORROR!!!!!!!  UofA is getting their preparations together for the Rose Bowl and the angry minions of ASU are gritting their teeth in despair.  "Dennis, Dennis, where art thou?" This was not supposed to happen!

Some dude from wherever : "Take care of the little things, and the big things will care for themselves"

The way ASU lost was more excruciating than the actual losses.  Missed PAT's, missed chip shot FG's, stupid penalties at the worst possible time, and you can go on and on and on.  After 9 games, ASU had a record of 4-5.  This included the two obligatory cupcakes and easy wins over Washington and Washington State.  It is ironic that ASU had very few penalties and no turnovers in the two Pac10 wins. 
 
"Take care of the little things..."  

One of the Sun Devil losses was a 1 pt loss to Rose Bowl bound Wisconsin.  The Badgers were helped by the Devils via a blown PAT and a missed chip shot FG.  The Sun Devils played physical and inspired against BCS Title game participant University of Oregon, but again 7 turnovers totally negated 600 yards of total offense by the Devils helping the Ducks to an 11 pt win.  The Devils traveled to LA-LA land to take on the Trojans and had the kicking game and an idiot penalty snag a defeat from victory.  ASU missed an easy chip shot FG as time ran out to secure USC's 1 point victory.  The stupid penalties and turnovers were not a mystery.  The kicking game collapse was.  ASU's field goal kicker was a senior who actually won the Lou Groza Award and was named first team All-American after his freshman season.  Who'd have figured?

By the end of the 9th game, number one topic of Sun Devil fans was whether Dennis Erickson should be given another year or not.  The lack of discipline on that team was beyond flukish or excusable.  Starting QB Steven Threet, although talented, had shown himself as a turnover machine.  How much playing time would the stubborn coach give Threet with talented and athletic Brock Osweiler sitting on the bench?  Could this team possibly play two games in a row without the noose of stupid, undisciplined penalties?  How long is the old coach going to hang on to a couple of his non-performing assistant coaches?  For all intents and purposes the season was over.

John Gruden: "It is really difficult to win a football game"

From a Sun Devil fans perspective, the 'Cat fans got a chance to experience the frustrations of damaging turnovers and a suicidal kicking game.  For the most part, the Wildcats played hard during this run of 0 wins and 5 losses, but turnovers, horribly placed penalties, missed opportunities, and blown kicks took away their chances to win the "coulda-shoulda" games. The once reliable Nick Foles was resembling Steven Threet with his interceptions into coverage when a 5 yard run for a first down was available.  It's tough to win games when the team is taking care of those little things, but let those slide and the difficulty level for winning becomes sky high.  Mix that factor in with your opponent taking care of business, then you have blow-out losses.

All I can say about Dennis Erickson and ASU is that a serendipitous moment may have occurred late in the first quarter of the UCLA game.  ASU was doing their typical nose dive performance until starting QB Steven Threet got hit and was removed from the game for a concussion.  In comes 6-8 250lb sophomore QB Brock Osweiler.  He totally reverses a deficit of about 17 points and leads the Devils to a 55-34 win.  He threw 5 TD passes, but more importantly 0 interceptions.  Against the Wildcats, he took advantage of 'Cat defenders not catching a couple of easy interceptions but eventually made them pay with his timely scrambles.  ASU would not have won that game with Steven Threet playing QB.  In my opinion, Dennis Erickson got a lucky break when Threet had to be taken out. Timely irony, in that ASU's psychotic FG kicker was a perfect 5 - 5 against the rival.  From this fan's perspective I was happy just to avoid the 3rd losing season in a row.  For some reason that became very important to me.


Coach Stoops

So, why should Mike Stoops be on the coaching "hot seat"?  Didn't he raise Wildcat football to the next level?  I find that statement to be highly disrespectful of great UofA coaches that have come before him?  I will agree that he raised the program to a level higher than John Mackovic had let it drop.  But so what? Mackovic had let it hit level ZERO.  In my opinion, Jim Young and Larry Smith were great football coaches that took over messes of previous regimes and Dick Tomey was a very good football coach for the University of Arizona.  Mike Stoops has not come close to the achievements of the former coaches.

A recent article in a local Tucson paper brought up the question "is Stoops burned out?"  Is the weight of the job getting to him?  I guess he made a comment back in November that he can't carry the burden of UofA never having played in the Rose Bowl game.  Can he even keep the program moving laterally?  I can't answer this.  But a couple of issues are becoming problematic for his program.

This season will be two seasons in a row that he must replace his offensive and defensive coordinator.  Not only have the coordinators left, but several other have left within the last year.  Some moves are due to coaches taking a more lucrative position such as a coordinator position, but the others have just decided to move on.

Coach Stoops mentioned this week that he may totally restructure his offense and defense.  This is after 7 years.  It's one thing to restructure with coaches already in place, but to totally change things with a new staff is difficult to do.

If he hangs tight next season with 7 wins or more, I think he will get another year.  But the new athletic director might have a different vision and want to move quicker if the season does not meet his expectations.

There isn't a fan rebellion at this time to remove Mike Stoops, as UofA fans have come to understand that changing coaches does not always work out positively.

Having said all that, next season is do or die for the Mike Stoops era at the UofA.  Keys are for him to develop a little more discipline and self-control in his own life and his side line behavior, that will transcend to his team and coaches.  Another is to get comfortable with an offensive scheme that he can understand and continue regardless of who takes over as Offensive Coordinator.  It would also help for the system to correlate to the players strengths.  At some point a coach has to understand who he is, what he wants, and how he will get there.  After 7 years, no more room for confusion.  Shoring up the kicking game would also aid in UofA's success next season.

Dennis Erickson 

Three factors finally got the fans off his butt as the season came to a close. 

He finished with a non-losing record by beating the rival.  Whipping UCLA and finally getting "Oz" on the field did not hurt. 

The team did not quit on him, as they played hard for all games this season, except for one.  The did play stupidly, but they did play physical and hard.

The abnormal number of kids he has returning next season.  ASU has participated in two dream seasons since they entered the Pac10.  A dream season, IMO, is participating in the Rose Bowl as the Pac10 champion.  The roster of the 1986/87 Rose Bowl team included 16 players who were on the two deep in 1984 and 19 players who were on the two deep in 1985.  The roster of the 1996/97 Rose Bowl team included 8 players who were on the two deep in 1994 and 17 who were on the two deep in 1995.  Obviously, each of those teams had experienced QB's that went through the seasoning process over that two year span.  Next season's squad will be without 5 players who were on ASU's two deep this season (Safety, WR, back up DL, Punter, Kicker).  That would be an astronomical 39 kids returning with starting or back-up experience.

As fans, we ultimately came to the conclusion that he must be allowed to finish his project.  Of concern would be that the projected QB will not be as experienced as we would have hoped, although the projected backup will have a ton of experience.  If this becomes a problem, that is a problem caused by the stubborn nature of the head coach.

Lou Holtz' advice to young coaches: "Don't get too close to your assistants.  One day you will have to fire them.  A good assistant will make you look good and bad assistants will get you fired"

Next season is do or die for Dennis Erickson.  The key is easier said than done for Erickson, and that is discipline.  That team must clean things up, in order to generate the number of wins expected by fans and outside observers.  No more room for ridiculous 15 yard penalties.  Lord knows, Erickson and staff need to have a competent kicker that can be trusted throughout the long season.

Erickson made a nice change in staff last season by dumping inept offensive coordinator Rich Olsen for Noel Mazzone.  Problem is that he still has a couple of more hanger-ons that aren't coaching well and offer ZERO on the recruiting front.  Those would be his long time friend and offensive line coach Gregg Smith and his son-in-law and TE/Special Teams coach Jamie Christiansen.  This year the state of Arizona has produced more blue-chip offensive linemen than anytime in history.  If we get one or two of them, that will be considered a victory.  The local players and coaches already know what the fan's know.  Erickson's stubborn attitude towards hanging on to his buddies could get him fired.

Both teams will have tough schedules next season.  To predict records is somewhat foolish as other teams have scholarship players, great coaches, and a will to win.  But for Dennis Erickson to save his job, he will need at least 8 wins next season.


 

4 comments:

  1. Hi Mike,

    Reading this post made me long for the days when ASU games didn't start at 10:30pm my time (now that I'm living in DC). And that's if I'm even able to get the game on my cable package. Honestly, I think the Wisconsin and UofA games were the only two I was able to watch this year...but what great games they were.

    Since I haven't exactly been following the teams (and since you specifically requested no trash talk), that substantially limits what I can contribute to this conversation. But here are my casual observations.

    I hadn't realized that ASU and never had 3 consecutive losing seasons. That's a great stat. Nor had I realized we were returning so many players next season. I know high school ball is different from college ball, but one of the reasons my high school had such a great run was the number of juniors and sophomores that logged significant playing time at the end of a dead-end season two years prior. I hope great things are in the works.

    Since I'm not a UofA fan, I'm not going to pretend to know what it will take to save Stoops' job. But I bet he, himself, is surprised that he's still the UofA coach after seven seasons. Not because he expected to get fired. But I bet by now he thought he'd be leading one of the more traditional college football powerhouses like his brother at OU. Seven years ago, they were both at the top of their games, but now it seems both of them have taken a hit on the public-perception front as their teams plateau.

    As for Erickson, I personally think it'll take more than 8 wins next year. I think it'll at least take a top-3 Pac10 finish, and probably even the Alamo Bowl. (Although, I guess 8 wins would have been sufficient for a top-3 finish this year since Stanford and Oregon ran roughshod over the rest of the Pac.)

    Personally, I was never really enthused when Erickson was hired. He's known as a "Player's Coach," but to me, "Player's Coach" is usually translated as "Undisciplined Team," which as your post indicated, is pretty much how things turned out this year. The recent 30 for 30 documentary on ESPN about Miami football in the '80s also demonstrated how undisciplined the Hurricanes were under Erickson. So I don't expect next year's penalty stats to be much improved. (On the other hand, I can't remember things being much better on the penalty front under Cutter either. I guess that's the one constant with ASU football over the better part of the last decade.)

    Anyway, I don't think I can offer much in the way of predictions for next year, since I only casually follow the teams anymore. But there is one bold prediction I'm willing to make. Actually, let's make it a riddle. Can anyone guess what Pac10 team WON'T be playing in the Rose Bowl for the 34th consecutive year? (Oh, wait...sorry. No trash talk. I forgot.)

    Go Devils!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Gosh darn it Jack. I just spent 20 minutes with a reply, and everything got so messed up in trying to send that my comment got deleted.

    Sucks to be tech illiterate.

    Try again later.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for the well thought comments, Jack.

    Why don't you give those two degenerate wildcat uncles of yours a heads up on their next Offensive Coordinator. In case you weren't aware, now that your an east coast guy, your alma mater fired their OC by the name of Anae. He took the job at UofA.

    Until the '08 and '09 losing seasons, ASU had not finished with consecutive season losing records since the year 1946. I guess you could say that ASU has been the ultimate model for mediocrity in the last 25 years. I was shocked to find that UofWash 7-6 record this sesaon ended a 6 year consecutive losing streak.
    Another example of how difficult it can be to replace a coach, even in a historically competivie program such as Washington. Each coach they would hire would be worse than the one they preceded.

    I agree with you about Erickson. I'm worried that cat just can't change his stripes. He must have it falsely implanted into his DNA that winning,agressive football and discipline are mutually exclusive events. Not surprising to me is that both of our Rose Bowl teams led the Pac10 in lowest number of penalties. I suggest if he wants to keep him and his family/buddies employed, discipline within the ranks should become a top priority.

    You mention your HS days at Ironwood HS. You guys had no shot your junior year against Saguaro HS, led by NFLer Mike Brown. He was definitely a man amongst boys in that game.

    I thought your coach really blew it my not accurately judging your strengths as a QB and potential CB. For those that read this and don't know, I'm not some disgruntled uncle that is mad because the coach did not play his nephew. Jack played and played well every game through the state finals (as he did his junior season). IMO, you were the classic option QB that was forced to play a more traditional stay in the pocket role. On those few occassions where you would implement the option, something successful would always occur. I'll never forget you taking the ball around the right end against Westview HS for 50+ yards and a TD. You had very good speed and outran all the Westview DB's. A couple of them were good track men. You would have been a great fit for the modern day "Pistol" as several HS's are now going with that scheme.

    Another negative memory was your senior year at home against Apollo(?). Ironwood had the ball on about their own 10 yd line with time running out in the first half. I don't fault your coach for his aggressive approach, but his play call was idiotic. He has you do a play-action pass. No one on the field or in the stands believed you were going to hand the ball off. Thus the play action caused you to have your back turned and you could not see the blitz coming in to hammer you. Luckily you didn't fumble. That play made as much sense as a Play-Action Pass on a Hail Mary.

    In the finals against Tempe HS, you should have gone both ways that game for the entire game. The state's best receiver, Justin Taplin, was eating up Ironwood's 5-6 and very slow CB. If not mistaken you actually got in a couple of plays at CB and it was apparent you could actually cover the guy. I know there were a couple of other mistakes along the way. That loss has to still sting as you guys had the better team (or at least I thought so).

    At any rate, Go Devils. I'm sick of screaming at them almost every game. Time for the worm to turn.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Haha. Sorry about the tech issues. Whenever I write comments, I always compose them in Word, then cut and paste them into the comment window. That way, if (or should I say when) things freeze up, I have a backup that I can post back in there.

    And...Ahhhh...the good ol' days. It's funny how I look back now and see all the things I should have done differently. I probably would have pushed the coach a little harder to play more CB. Its funny looking back, how much you respect/fear authority when you're only 17 and the coaches are 32. But now that I'm 32, I think, why the heck didn't I just ask him? What was he going to do, bench me?

    I don't think I would have wanted to play full time both ways, but every third possession or maybe nickle situations would have been nice. I'm not going to pretend I would have been able to shut down Taplin or anything, but I know I wouldn't have let him run free on the OT touchdown.

    I also would have definitely blown off the coaches play call on the RB-to-WR-reverse that we ended up fumbling away in the last seconds of regulation (and within FG range) against Tempe.

    Anyway, regardless of how things turned out in the championship games, I count my blessings every day that I even had the chance to play in that situation. Most high school football players struggle through mediocre seasons where the last 2 or 3 games don't mean anything. In fact, I count my blessings that I had such a wonderful high school experience -- not only in football, but everything else as well. Ninety percent of the people I talk to about high school describe what a humiliating and depressing time they had, and how it was the worst experience of their life. I was sooo lucky to have the high school experience that I did. No bitterness at all...even if I do still have "visions of Mike Brown dancing through my head."

    Anyway, thanks for the kind words. And Fork'em Devils!

    ReplyDelete