I continue the fight for them

I continue the fight for them
Daylen and Grandad at the beach

Saturday, June 18, 2011

Radio interview with David Mamet

About a week ago I listened to a radio interview with David Mamet.  David Mamet was a traditional Hollywood liberal who took his father's advice to truly understand his political stance and the stance of others from the other side.  Mr. Mamet has written a new book "The Secret Knowledge:  On the dismantling of American Culture."

David Mamet is an acclaimed playwright, screenwriter, film director, and essayist. Some of his most famous works include the films The Untouchables, The Verdict, and Wag the Dog, the last two nominated for an Academy Award, and many plays, including American Buffalo and Glengarry Glen Ross, for which he was awarded the Pulitzer Prize.

Mr. Mamet speaks of his metamorphosis:

"My interest in politics began when I noticed that I acted differently than I spoke, that I had seen 'the government' commit sixty years of fairly unrelieved and catastrophic error nationally and internationally, that I not only hated every wasted hard-earned cent I spent in taxes, but the trauma and misery they produced..."

For the past thirty years, David Mamet has been a controversial and defining force in theater and film, championing the most cherished liberal values along the way. In some of the great movies and plays of our time, his characters have explored the ethics of the business world, embodied the struggles of the oppressed, and faced the flaws of the capitalist system.

But in recent years Mamet has had a change of heart. He realized that the so- called mainstream media outlets he relied on were irredeemably biased, peddling a hypocritical and deeply flawed worldview. In 2008 he wrote a hugely controversial op-ed for The Village Voice, "Why I Am No Longer a 'Brain- Dead Liberal,'" in which he methodically eviscerated liberal beliefs. Now he goes much deeper, employing his trademark intellectual force and vigor to take on all the key political and cultural issues of our times, from religion to political correctness to global warming. A sample:

The problems facing us, faced by all mankind engaged in Democracy, may seem complex, or indeed insolvable, and we, in despair, may revert to a state of wish fulfillment-a state of "belief" in the power of the various experts presenting themselves as a cure for our indecision. But this is a sort of Stockholm Syndrome. Here, the captives, unable to bear the anxiety occasioned by their powerlessness, suppress it by identifying with their captors.

This is the essence of Leftist thought. It is a devolution from reason to "belief," in an effort to stave off a feeling of powerlessness. And if government is Good, it is a logical elaboration that more government power is Better. But the opposite is apparent both to anyone who has ever had to deal with Government and, I think, to any dispassionate observer.

It is in sympathy with the first and in the hope of enlarging the second group that I have written this book.


Mamet pulls no punches in his art or in his politics. And as a former liberal who woke up, he will win over an entirely new audience of others who have grown irate over America's current direction.

The following is an abbreviated transcript of the interview between radio host and David Mamet.

HOST:  What were the catalysts that made you question your liberalism?


DM: Well, I think the first one was around the 2004 election, and I went to synagogue, as I do regularly.  The rabbi was talking about political civility, and he said it's in the Judeo-Christian that before you criticize someone you have to sit down with them and restate their position to them such that they will say , "Yes, that is what I mean," and they have to state your position to you so that you say, "Yes," so you both agree that you understand what the positions are, then you each introduce your facts.  So I wanted to ... I took the advice to heart.  I said: "Well, as a good liberal I better be able to state the conservative position." (chuckles) So I started researching and I started reading, and it dawned on me that I was not a liberal, that although I could state the position of who I thought were my enemies, the conservatives, I could not rationally state the position of the liberals.

HOST:  So you've undergone the process, you've written the book, "The Secret Knowledge: On the Dismantling of American Culture," and, by the way, the title's kind of clever. There's no "secret knowledge," correct?  

DM:  Yeah, the secret knowledge is there's nobody home but us chickens.  The Constitution was written by a bunch of regular guys who tried to get together and thrash out a contract under which they could get together that would keep people together as it has for 230 years.  And that when the experts come in claiming to be Messiahs or saviors -- or indeed experts in politician -- what they are, they're either deluded for the most part or they're duplicitous, because they should be there serving our interests; and there is no knowledge greater than that of the citizen. 


HOST: What was it like?  Was there a moment when the light went off and you said to yourself, "Everything I've believed for so much of my life I've been wrong about"?  

DM:  Yes, I think so. I'd just started reading Milton Friedman.  And I felt, as the phrase has it, "The scales fell from my eyes," because he took what I thought was an impenetrable subject, economics, which was susceptible only to intellectuals and people that understood it. 

HOST:  What did you think was impenetrable about economics?  

DM:  I don't know, because I never looked at it.  I knew that it was called "the dismal science" and I knew there were books full of graphs.


HOST:  But you've earned your living in capitalism and science and economics and so forth. It's made you who financially you are.


DM:  Exactly so! But the realization that I came to is that each citizen for himself or herself understands the economics, which is, "I better make more than I spend and I better put something aside for a rainy day, and I want to get a good idea about what to do with the surplus so that perhaps it can grow while I'm sleeping."  Period.  And that's capitalism.  Everybody practices it, but half of the country -- those on the left -- deny that it's true.

HOST:  Right, and that's a fascinating thing.  People live their lives that way.  Most people do, but when it comes time to vote, they'll vote the exact opposite of their interests in that regard.  In other words, people are charitable and they'll donate to causes but they will not walk down the street and give money from their pockets to everybody that lives on the street.  But they'll vote for people who will do it for them.  

DM:  Exactly so.  And the question that they won't ask is: Where does all that money end up?  Where does the aid to Africa end up?  Most of it ends up diverted into the pockets either of the politicians or crooks. Some of it may get where it's going but just a little bit of it -- and I'll tell you a story.  An old friend of mine, who's now in her 90s -- she's a German immigrant -- she and her husband came here after the War without absolutely nothing; not a penny, not a word of the language; and their patron, their sponsor deserted them.  So they arrived in this little town and they spent 40 years there and became fixtures in the town; and after September 11th she was knitting sweaters to send to the rescue workers and the relief workers; and I said, "That's such a great charitable act, but don't you...?" These sweaters are magnificent.  They're handmade woolen sweaters, great works of arts.  I said: "Most of them aren't going to get to the people they're intended to. They're going to disappear along the way."
  
She nodded and she said:  "Well, maybe some of them will get through." She had seen much more of life than I had, and she felt it was her duty to do something personal in spite of the fact that it might not work -- and that's kind of how I feel about us citizens.  Rather than saying, "Oh, it's not going to work," or, "We can't get together," we have to do what we can in spite of the fact that failure is always possible. 

HOST:   Do you have the belief that people on the left are less desirous of getting together?  We always hear about "civility" and "we have to get along."  People don't like all this "partisanship" and so forth, but the burden always seems to fall on conservatives.  We seem to have to be the first ones that are told we must compromise what we believe in order to get this mutual adoration society going.  There seems to be an arrogance and a condescension attitudinally among people on the left that seems to prevent them from having any desire to actually commingle.  

DM:  Well, like Lincoln said: "If slavery is not wrong, nothing is wrong," and I feel the same way about the leftist dismantling of the West.  If that's not wrong, then nothing is wrong -- and I've got a good model for people saying, "Perhaps the truth lies somewhere in between," and that's the state of Israel which has been defending itself daily against constant attack for 60 years from people whose avowed purpose is to kill every Jew in Israel and then to kill the rest of the Jews in the world.  People on the left say, "Yes, but obviously if there's two parties to the dispute, the truth must lie somewhere in between," and I don't see where the truth lies in between in Israel and I really don't see where the truth lies in between the liberals and the conservatives.  The liberals say, "Are you arguing there must be no government?" Of course not.  I'm arguing that the government should be representative of the people's interests. 

HOST:  ....where do we compromise? And that's a great point that you're making.  But just because somebody has a side, does it become legitimate?  It could be totally illegitimate.

DM:  That's right.  Dennis Prager says he "prefers 'clarity' to 'agreement.'"  I think that's a great phrase to live one's life by.  Woodrow Wilson did a lot towards screwing up the world.  But he did say a couple of smart things. "You can vote for freedom and you'll probably lose, or you can vote for slavery and you'll absolutely win."  

HOST:  ....how long have you held the belief that you're sharing with us now that you didn't act on for so many years?   

DM:   I was a liberal, which meant that I voted for the liberal team.  It meant that... You know what it meant? It meant that I was excused from thinking. 
  
HOST:  Were you born liberal and then confirmed --or you just didn't question the way you were?  

DM:  My dad was an immigrant kid and a Democrat and a Jew, and we didn't know any Republicans in our group.  So I grew up Democratic.  My dad was a labor lawyer -- a very hardworking guy, a one horse labor lawyer -- and then I went to hippie college and lived in the bubble.  I didn't knowingly meet a conservative until, to my shame, I was 60 years old and sat down and said, "Wow, I don't understand what this guy's talking about, but he has a great civility about him. Perhaps I better investigate this thing."

HOST:  Are you able to talk to liberal friends now that you've, quote/unquote, "come out"?  What's the impact been on your friendships?  

DM:  Well, that's a good question.  I have a lot of friends.  I don't socialize a lot because I've got a family, so I go home at night and I don't socialize a lot.  But I see my friends occasionally.  We all work together.  My definition of a "friend" is, coming from Chicago, someone who says, "Yeah, sure. You know what? Let's talk about what we can talk about. Let's help each other out. Your politics are none of my business."  And that's how we work in the workplace. 

HOST:  But you now  feel the need to proselytize.  You've written a book.  You're attempting to convert others, correct?   

DM:  Well, I don't know.  That's a very good question.  I wrote the book to try to figure out what I thought.  I said, "I've got to sit down with pencil and paper."  It's like taking the car apart to learn how the internal combustion engine works.  It's not enough to just take it to the garage and give the guy a couple bucks.  I want to know how the car works.  So that's what I was doing with my own thought processes -- attempting to do -- and that's what I was doing was attempting to understand what democracy actually is.  So as I said at the end of the book, "I wrote this in sympathy with anyone who has been oppressed by big government."   And then the hope of drawing the attention of this terror to the fair minded. 



 


 






 









   

2 comments:

  1. More from David Mamet regarding his political shift. From an interview with an online magazine:
    _________________________________________

    Mamet has just written a book, “The Secret Knowledge: On the Dismantling of American Culture”

    He said he started to seek out the conservative viewpoint because, in Hollywood, he just didn’t know that it existed. “I did a few years’ worth of reading and came to a different understanding of economics and philosophy.”

    But Mamet, who won his Pulitzer for the play “Glengarry Glen Ross” and also wrote such classics as “American Buffalo” and “Speed-the-Plow,” said he does not want to get more involved in politics or endorse a candidate for the next election. “I don’t know better than the next guy,” he pointed out.

    “My lesson is that the three branches of government, having failed to uphold the Constitution and the press having failed to uphold its responsibility to tell the truth, there’s nobody home but us chickens.

    “Us chickens are the votership and we citizens are going to have to make up our minds and vote according to the understanding of our responsibilities.”

    Mamet's rightward turn is evident when he says the United States needs a president like Benjamin Netanyahu rather than Barack Obama.

    Mamet says he noticed the difference between the two world leaders during the Israeli prime minister’s address to Congress last month.

    “I heard [Obama’s] speech, and I read Prime Minister Netanyahu’s speech and I said to myself, ‘Why can’t we, America, have a leader like Netanyahu because we sure as hell need one,” Mamet said during an exclusive interview with Newsmax.TV.

    Mamet said his fellow Chicagoan comes from a long line of presidents, including Franklin D. Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson, “who have never worked a day in their life.”

    “It’s the vision of the anointed, that they had somehow been anointed and they know better than everyone else around them,” he said.

    Mamet had particularly harsh words for Obama’s Middle East policies. “To see the left’s abandonment of Israel was profoundly sobering,” he said.

    “The Israelis, and us Jews by extension, are now being treated basically as sub-humans by the left, that is to say people to whom the international law and traditional considerations of right and wrong, traditional considerations of mutual responsibilities to allies, did not apply.

    “There is no difference between this view and the view that 15th-century Jews were going around poisoning the wells and kidnapping the Christian children for their blood,” he said, adding, “The only difference is that the left of today is saying it is ridiculous to think that Jews delight in the killing of Christian children — of course they don’t, they delight in the killing of Muslim children!”

    The days when Jews voted en bloc for Democrats could be coming to an end, but it will take time as it is ingrained, generation after generation, he said.

    “It takes a great effort because it feels like two things: it feels like treason and it feels like heresy,” he said.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Bits and Pieces from Mamet's book:

    Mamet was suddenly exposed to ideas he had never encountered before.

    "Shelby Steele's 'White Guilt,'" he said, "led me to the works of Tom Sowell and through them (F.A.) Hayek and Milton Friedman."

    Two things hit him especially hard: the benefits of economic competition and the limits of leaders' ability to plan society.

    "If you stop licensing taxi cabs, tomorrow you will see guys and women on every street corner saying, 'Who wants to go to XYZ address?' (The cabbie) will put five people in the car and drive them to that address. ... When the guy drops them off, if he's smart, he'll say: 'Tomorrow -- same thing, right? What do you guys want to drink for breakfast?' There will be cappuccino and ice tea and glass of milk. After X months, he will have three cars; after X months, he will have a fleet. And everyone will be competing to meet the needs of the commuters, which also is going to reduce traffic. Why are they allowed to compete? Because the government got the hell out of the business."

    Mamet also read Hayek's last book, "The Fatal Conceit."

    "What Hayek is talking about is that we have to have a constrained vision of the universe. The unconstrained vision, the liberal vision, is that everything can be done, everything is accomplishable," he said. "We don't have the knowledge. ... There is only so much that government can do. ... It would be nice if giving all of our money to the government could cure poverty. Maybe, but giving money to the government causes slavery."

    For Hayek, the "fatal conceit" is the premise that politicians and bureaucrats can make the world better -- not by leaving people free to coordinate their private individual plans in the marketplace -- but by overall social and economic planning.

    Imagine trying to plan an economy, Mamet said, when we barely know enough to raise our kids. "(T)he guy in government can't know everything."

    As you can imagine, when Mamet went public, he bewildered many of his showbiz peers. A Los Angeles Times critic called his book "a children's crusade with no understanding of real politics." The Nation called Mamet a "great playwright, (but a) moronic political observer."

    Mamet said to his wife: 'Isn't it funny? ... The New York Times, the supposed newspaper of record that has been reviewing my plays for 40 years, isn't even going to review this book.'

    "She says: 'Dave, grow up. The purpose of all newspapers is political."

    Maybe the Times thinks it's insignificant that a celebrated cultural "liberal" now questions his faith in the supposed healing power of government. But as we sit mired in this endless jobless "recovery," with the wreckage of government failure all around, we should ask ourselves which one is out of touch with reality.

    ReplyDelete