Attacking a deepening jobs crisis, President Barack Obama challenged a reluctant Congress Thursday night to urgently pass a larger-than-expected $450 billion plan to "jolt an economy that has stalled." He urged lawmakers to slash Social Security taxes for tens of millions of Americans and for almost every business to encourage hiring.
By most accounts, President Obama’s $800 billion “stimulus” bill that was passed in February 2009 with the promise of keeping unemployment below 8 percent was an absolute failure. However, last night in a speech to a joint session of Congress, the President demanded that it spend another $450 billion on more of the same “stimulus” that has left America with zero job growth and continued economic stagnation. But don’t worry. His top economic adviser Gene Sperling told NBC that this one would likely get us down to 8 percent.
Despite Sperling’s predictions, there are a lot of problems with the broad outlines in the President’s proposal, not the least of which is the fact that President Obama is insisting Congress immediately pass a bill that doesn’t exist. No legislative details have been offered; nothing has been scored by the Congressional Budget Office; there has been no debate or negotiation; and there is no accompanying plan on how to pay for it. President Obama only promised he would talk about paying for it in the weeks to come, and that onus likely will fall on the congressional “super committee” that was supposed to be focused on reducing our debt.
"Stop the political circus," an animated Obama told a joint session of Congress in a nationally televised speech. Over and over he implored lawmakers to "pass this jobs bill."
Open to discussion but making no promises, Republican House Speaker John Boehner said Obama's ideas would be considered but the president should give heed to Republicans' as well. "It's my hope that we can work together," he said.
In announcing a plan heavy on the tax cuts that Republicans traditionally love, Obama sought to achieve multiple goals: offer a plan that could actually get through a deeply divided Congress, speed hiring in a nation where 14 million are out of work, shore up public confidence in his leadership and put Republicans on the spot to take action.
Obama never estimated how many jobs would be created by his plan, which also includes new federal spending for construction, hiring and an extension of jobless benefits for the long-term unemployed. Despite his promise that it would all be paid for, he has not yet released the details on how.
President Obama wants to extend unemployment benefits yet again as a way to boost the economy. That just won’t work. For welfare reasons Congress wants to help workers who cannot find jobs. This is understandable. That doesn’t mean it will help the economy, no matter how much the President wants it to.
The stimulus bill extended unemployment benefits, Congress has kept them in place several times since then, and the federal government has spent over $300 billion on unemployment benefits since Obama took office. It hasn’t stimulated the economy before. It’s not going to stimulate it now.
Obama proposed spending to fix schools and roads, hire local teachers and police and extend unemployment benefits.
Throwing more money at building roads and bridges, President Obama tells us, will create new jobs. So he is proposing the creation of an infrastructure bank that would require a whole new bureaucracy.
Increasing spending on these projects “simply moves resources from one place to another — it may employ construction workers, but only by reducing jobs in other sectors.” And taxpayers end up paying the price, all without creating net job growth or boosting the economy in the near term.
America’s education system needs less federal involvement, not more. But the President used his jobs speech as a way to shoehorn the federal government further into the education business, proposing that Washington spend billions on school construction and new jobs for teachers. Never mind that since 1970, school enrollment in public elementary and secondary schools has increased just 7 percent, while staff hires have increased 83%.
On a per-pupil basis, federal spending on education has nearly tripled since the 1970′s. And for all that spending, Washington hasn’t improved results.
The White House put the price tag of Obama's plan at $447 billion, with about $253 billion in tax cuts and $194 billion in federal spending.
As to paying for it, Obama will ask a special debt panel in Congress to find enough savings to cover the costs of his ideas. He says he'll release specifics a week from Monday along with a proposal to stabilize the country's long-term debt.
A couple of years ago Erskin Bowles and Alan Simpson were asked by the White House to submit a plan to confront the economic crisis. Although imperfect, it was honestly an great place to start. Upon receiving this plan, the White House put it on the bag burner, never attempting to use it as start to economic recovery. This was during his early administration where he proclaimed to all Republicans that he won (and had control of both Houses) and the Republicans can just sit in the back of the bus. Obviously, he had his own personal agenda and the Bowles/Simpson plan was not conducive to that.
Most of the $447 billion package would be spent in 2012. The White House says Obama's as-yet-unrevealed plan for payment would spread the cost over the long term, likely over 10 years.
Numerous times (most recently during the Reagan and Papa Bush presidencies) the Republicans were promised that if spending were allowed to increase NOW, that spending cuts/tax breaks would be delivered later. Not one time was that promise kept by the Democrat leadership. Really, spreading the payment plan over 10 years? The current administration will be long gone over the span of this projected 10 year plan. Fool me once........
This man, President Obama can no longer be trusted. He promised to “root out” unnecessary regulations, as he has for four straight years, while only adding more costly rules to the books. He proposed extending the payroll tax “holiday,” which will not create jobs. He ignored serious ways to grow the economy, like pursuing domestic energy production, which he himself has stalled. He passed $830 billion in stimulus, $3 billion for cash for clunkers, $30 billion in small business loans, $30 billion for mortgage modification, the GM-Chrysler bailouts, ObamaCare, Dodd-Frank, credit card price controls, Build America Bonds, jobless benefits for a record 99 weeks, and more. Every thing he proposes is about his personal ideologies and re-election. Damn American exceptionalism.
President Obama has spent two and a half years increasing federal spending, growing government, and punishing businesses with burdensome regulations, and today 14 million Americans remain unemployed. Now the President is demanding more of the same at an even higher price. That is not a plan to create new jobs–that is a politically motivated message that ignores the reality of America’s economic crisis.
Obamanomics could be labeled as a legitimate "ponzi" scheme. We spend money now at a record pace to supposed promises of greatness down the road. Somehow generations from now we’re supposed to be able to pay for current spending, but that of course is always left out of the plan. Obama’s supposed jobs speech is filled with more “stimulus” spending with buzz words like investments or infrastructure spending. Increased taxes on the supposed rich will be where Obama claims to get this money. Further taxing on an already overtaxed nation will do nothing but stifle possible job creation as investors and entrepreneurs either save their money or use it elsewhere. Just like the Ponzi Scheme it is doomed to fail.
A pig is a pig, no matter how much lipstick you put on it.
Probably your best post ever!
ReplyDeleteDaneille
Make that "best political post". Your post to Daylen about her mother/heritage is my sentimental favorite. For some reason, I can't comment on your blog with my Google account lately, so I've been frustrated at not being able to publish my responses to you. But since 'anonymous' works, let me say now how much I've appreciated reading your thoughts about all different subjects. Very informative in some cases, touching in others, and sometimes just fun.
ReplyDeleteDaneille
Thanks D for the comments.
ReplyDelete