I continue the fight for them

I continue the fight for them
Daylen and Grandad at the beach

Thursday, December 1, 2011

TWO PROGRAMS, TWO COACHES HIT THE ROAD

Last January I wrote a piece titled TWO PROGRAMS, TWO COACHES AT THE CROSSROADS.  Well, both coaches were told to hit the road.

Before I continue on this topic, I offer my congratulations to the UofA in their victory over ASU.  UofA was hard to figure out, but I knew they could not be taken lightly.  They could look "lights out" one game (UCLA) and then look like they want the season to end in others.  I give them credit for getting themselves up and prepared to whip their rivals.

ASU became easy to figure out.  After the 6-2 start and having gone through the toughest part of their schedule, they drop four games in a row.  What was a very opportunistic defense went into the dumper.  FG kicker blew a couple of games that could have kept them breathing.  And we could go on from there.  Essentially, Dennis Erickson is who many thought he was.  Not one to instill discipline and focus to his troops.  His practice sessions and inter-action with the players did nothing for building character and perseverance.  Erickson and Dirk Koetter both made a common critical mistake during their terms at ASU.  They hired too many old friends and relatives as their assistant coaches.  When those coaches showed they could not get the job done, they were not fired.  How do you fire your buddy, your son, or your son-in-law?

As stated before, Lou Holtz's  #1 piece of advice to young coaches is this:

"Don't get too close to your assistant coaches.  One day you will have to fire them.  A good assistant will make you look good and a bad assistant coach will get you fired."  

Truer words were never spoken.

Because I am not close to the UofA football program, I don't know of all the specifics of Mike Stoops demise. Ultimately, it always comes down to wins and losses.  I find some irony in that the defensive guru had problems on defense, but his offense was great. 

At some point in time you have to get to the big show.  It's an unforgiving business, but they are well paid and know the rules of this business.  "Just win, baby"

I hate this merry-go round of changing staffs every 5 to 7 years.  History has shown me that hiring a great fit for your university is nothing more than rolling the dice and hoping to hit your double-sevens.  All prospective coaches have a flaw or two.  Sometimes a flaw has not been revealed at one school, only to rear it's ugly head at another.

99% of the fans always think the new guy is the "home-run" hire.  I've said it and I'm sure all of you have said it.  Know one really knows.

Pete Carroll was literally the 6th or 7th coach to be offered the job at USC.  Trojan fans were griping all over the place about Mike Garrett screwing up the hire.  Jim Harbaugh was a quick hire after a couple of other coaches refused Stanford and they were running out of time.  Thus, Jim Harbaugh was a "stop the bleeding" type of hire.  Contrary to popular opinion, Harbaugh was not the "hot" up and comer.   When ASU was looking for a coach the last time around, the name of Harbaugh came up.  I said "Naw, he doesn't have enough big time experience as a Head Coach."  Now I think he is one of the top football coaches in America.  What do I know!

I'm almost to the place where the George Costanza approach is the way to success.  Remember that episode where he discovered that when he followed the popular logic of doing things, he always failed.  But when he went against the grain and did what he thought would be wrong, he hit gold.  It might be that a program would benefit from hiring the guy that no one else is happy with.

I've seen excerpts and reviews on a book written in 2002,  Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game.  I guess this book was made into a movie this year.

The book focuses on the Oakland Athletics and how they achieved success over their competition, without breaking the bank to do so.  The Athletic's staff went against the "collective wisdom" of baseball insiders.  The A's General Manager, Billy Beane, became a proponent of sabermetrics or the rigorous use of variable statistical analysis to determine what was really important in building a team, compared to the subjective conventional wisdom of the network of "good old boys" in the sport.

Beane's analysis showed that 'on base percentage' and 'slugging percentage' were better indicators of offensive success than 'RBIs' and 'batting average'.

Using this methodology allowed the A's ($41 million payroll) to become competitive with the big boys, such as the Yankees ($125 million payroll).  Having success with the sabermetric principles has led to a paradigm shift that many MLB teams now use in putting together a team.  I've been told that the new leadership of the Diamondbacks uses this approach.

One great year for a coach at a mid-level football school always leads to that coach being the new "hot hire".  A successful big time coach in one BCS conference may totally fail when taking his system to another conference.  In other words, wins and losses can be a deceiving indicator of that coaches system being successful at all schools and conferences.

I followed too many failures in coaching hires to know that one must look past the "bling and mojo" and peel back a few more layers of the onion, in order to concentrate on the pure substance of each potential hire.

If I were the Athletic Director making a football hire, I would consider five factors with much more sincerity than I did a few years ago.  Hiring a coach is always a roll of the dice.  My hope would be to move the probability of success towards my favor, in order to lessen the risk of this very expensive hire.

1.  I will not consider a coordinator or assistant for my hire.  They just don't have a substantial body of work in which to help me judge his potential success.  

The most successful hires done in this matter have been when a successful coach retires and his hand picked assistant is chosen to be the next leader.  One example is Brent Bielema who is now the HC at the University of Wisconsin.  The only change to that successful program was the HC.  Nothing else has changed.  It is a very smooth transition, such that the players and community barely recognized any change has been made.

When researching the number of successes and failures of assistant coaches moving from one university to another has shown more failures than successes.  The most successful hire of this type was when Bob Stoops moved from being the defensive coordinator at Florida to becoming the head coach at Oklahoma.  

2.  What is the "bounce-back" factor for this potential hire?  What is the candidate's ability to handle adversity?  

No coach is going to win every game.  Sometimes a coach will go through a tough experience with his team for reasons out of his immediate control.

What is his record in bouncing back from a loss?  Does he bounce back from losing seasons?  In other words, does his resume include a recent history of losing streaks.  I believe this factor reveals the candidate's real coaching ability.

3.  What is the coaches pedigree?  If you look at the list of great coaches, you will see they were assistant's to great coaches that came before them.  Seems like a lot of the great coaches of today and yesteryear are from the family tree of Woody Hayes, Bo Schembechler, and Lou Holtz.

4.  I want a coach that believes in balance across the program.  I want to see a commitment to run, pass, special teams, and defense.  Different schemes can implement balance, so the schemes they use are not that important to me.

5.  What is the coach's record in recent games decided by 7 pts or less.

A history of losing close games while winning big in other games does not impress me. To win more close games than you lose, reveals a tough, well-conditioned, and disciplined team.  To win by blowouts in most of your games only suggests your talent level is superior.  What happens when the talent level has a drop?


I will use these factors to assess the recent hires made by UofA and ASU.

Rich Rodriguez (University of Arizona)





https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhEWTx7zcSucQ1k3WWXKABlMqU_s6H8hBbDS0SQRw0KG2O9feEWiHjlIYkCC2sAcdaCENrx92e5ODYUDP0DuyqpdRYGLNl-azsBXam49EzwYiJLN6Itglqe0bSnD7zJCT_awMnUztmLaGrQ/s1600/Rich+Rodriguez+2.jpg

1. Rich Rodriguez has a substantial body of work.  The problem is to discern the reasons for his success at West Virginia and his failures at Michigan.

His record in 7 years at West Virginia was very good.  2001: 3-8  2002: 9-4  2003: 8-5  2004: 8-4  2005: 11-1  2006: 11-2  2007: 10-2 (he did not coach the bowl game due to accepting the job at Michigan)

His record was impressive and most believed he would continue his success at University of Michigan.  But it was a failure hire from the very beginning.

2008: 3-9  2009: 5-7  2010: 7-6

Using 20-20 hindsight, his problems at Michigan were all on the defensive side.  His offense was scoring enough points to win more games.

In 2010, Michigan gave up 455 yds per game in Total Defense.  In 2011 under Brady Hoke, Michigan gave up 318 yds per game.

In each of Rodriguez' 3 years at Michigan, his Total Defense ranking was in the 100's out of 120 schools being ranked.  In 2011, the defense is ranked #13.

In 2010, Michigan gave up 265 yds per game in pass defense.  In 2011, Michigan gave up 189 yds per game.

In 2010, Michigan gave up 190 yds per game in rush defense.  In 2011, Michigan gave up 129 yds per game.

In 2010, Michigan gave up 35.1 points per game.  In 2011, Michigan has given up 17.2 points per game.

So how did a coach that had decent defenses at West Virginia have so much trouble in that regard at University of Michigan.  Of course, I don't know the real answer but I can take a clue from ASU's negative experience with Dirk Koettter.

When Koetter came on board, he made the comment that as long as you outscore the other team, then the defense is good enough.  He brought with him a poor defensive staff, including a horrible defensive coordinator.  He also used a 4-2-5 defense.  I've seen the 4-2-5 work well at other schools, such as TCU, but it may be that it doesn't work as well in other conferences.  ASU became a better defensive team when Koetter's bust of a DC was hired on as HC at Utah State (Brent Guy went on to have a horrible record at Utah State). The new defensive coordinator immediately went to the more traditional 4-3-4 and ASU had much more success in his one or two years at the job.  Problem is, that it was too little and too late.

Rodriguez used the 3-3-5 defense that worked well in the Big East but he was resistant to change his defense and his coordinator while at Michigan.  In my opinion, that was his waterloo.  Of interest to UofA fans will be his adjustments made on this side of the ball. If he makes the proper moves, then he should be successful.

2.  In his first season at West Virginia, he had 1 streak of 4 consecutive losses and 1 streak of 3 consecutive losses.  In 2003, he had a streak of 3 consecutive losses only 1 time.  Same in 2004.  Only having a bad season his first year at West Virginia, he obviously did not allow losing streaks to accumulate.

The Michigan story is a bit different. In 2008, he had 1 losing streak of 5 games and 1 losing streak of 2 games.  In 2009, he had the same record in losing streaks as in 2008.  In 2010, he had 2 losing streaks of 3 games.

3. With his total years of head coaching experience, pedigree is not that important a factor in coming to some conclusions about his ability to be a winner.  It is amazing how few years he spent as an assistant for other coaches.

In 1985 he was a graduate assistant for Don Nehlen at West Virginia. Ironic that Rodriguez replaced Nehlen 16 years later, when Nehlen was fired.

Nehlen was then the HC of a couple of NAIA schools before joining the staff at Tulane in '97-'98 as the offensive coordinator.  The head coach he worked for was Tommy Bowden.  Tulane was Rodriguez other suitor prior to UofA offering him the job.

He joined Bowden at Clemson for the '99-'00 seasons at OC.

In 2001, Rodriguez took the offer at West Virginia to be their next head coach.  For what it's worth, there may have been a strong Bowden influence in his selection, as "daddy" Bobby Bowden made his first big impression on the national football scene at West Virginia many years earlier.

4.  It appears from his 2010 statistics that Rodriguez tends more to the run than he does the pass.  To me that is a good thing.  As stated earlier, his offense was very capable even at Michigan.

Rush attempts: 43 per game   Pass attempts: 30 per game
Net Punt Average: 36.1 yds   FG's:  4-14  PAT's: 56-58

We all know how a bad FG kicker can ruin potentially good seasons.  

5.  During Rodriguez' tenure at West Virginia, his record in games decided by 7 points or less was 13-10.  IMO, that's good.

The Michigan story is different.  His record in games decided by 7 points or less was 7-7.  His first two seasons, his record in close games was 3-7, but in his final year at Michigan he was 4-0 in close games.

There is one other stat that has you going, "huh".  Look at the 2010 scores by quarter:

SCORE BY QUARTERS     1st  2nd  3rd  4th  OT     Total
--------------------  ---  ---  ---  ---  ---      ---
Michigan............  122   83   95  104   22  -   426
Opponents...........   64  194   92   88   20  -   458

 His Michigan team led every quarter but the second.  He continually got hammered in that quarter.  I have no reasons why this happened, but it is something to ask about if I am the A.D.

So did UofA make a high risk or a low risk hire?  I would say that it was a pretty safe hire.  That Michigan debacle can't be ignored, but if he truly learned from past mistakes and is willing to make changes, then I would say UofA made a good hire.
_______________________________________________________
I will post on ASU's hire when it is made official.  Check in when a hire is made.
_______________________________________________________


Todd Graham  (Arizona State University)


http://media.lehighvalleylive.com/sports_impact/photo/todd-graham-standing-278155a5fa13702d.jpg 

 1.  Todd Graham has been a head coach at three different universities, resulting in a resume that includes 6 years as a university head football coach.  Due to one year stints at Rice and at Pitt, the only way to evaluate his body of work would be to focus on his term at University of Tulsa.

In 2006, Graham accepted his first head coaching assignment at Rice University.  During his one and only season at Rice, the team suffered through losses in their first four games to Houston (1 pt), UCLA, Texas, and Florida State.  The Owls finished the rest of the season with a record of 7-2, which included a loss in their first bowl game in 45 years.

Prior to his stint at Rice, the Owls were coached by Ken Hatfield who instituted a wishbone offense.  His records during his last 4 years at Rice were 4-7, 5-7, 3-8, and 1-10.  Todd Graham had to transition his Rice squad from the wishbone to an offense that resembled the spread option.


Prior to the 2007 season,  head coach Steve Kragthorpe left Tulsa to become the head coach of University of Louisville.  Kragthorpe's four seasons at Tulsa resulted in records of 8-5, 4-8, 9-4, and 8-5 (29-22 total).


In Graham's four seasons at Tulsa, he accumulated a total record of 36-17.  He posted the first back to back 10 plus win seasons in the history of University of Tulsa football.  Graham's offensive coordinator at Tulsa was good friend Gus Malzahn, another very successful high school coach that made the jump from the preps to offensive coordinator at University of Arkansas.  This season Todd Dodge was the QB coach at Pitt under Todd Graham.  Dodge made the jump from a very successful stint at South Lake Carrol in Texas to the HC position at North Texas State.  After being fired at North Texas, Dodge joined Graham at Pitt.  It appears that Graham will not be bringing Dodge with him to ASU.  Todd Graham has tremendous recruiting ties and contacts in Oklahoma,Texas, and Louisiana.  Will be interesting to see how that translates into his recruiting strategy at ASU.


2007 (10-4) - Tulsa led the nation in total offense with 544 ypg.  This team was the first in NCAA history to have a 5,000 yd passer, a 1000 yd rusher, and 3 different receivers with over 1000 yds in receptions.


2008 (11-3) - Again, Tulsa led the nation in total offense with 570 ypg.  They were ranked fifth in rushing (268 ypg) and ninth in passing (302 ypg).

2009 (5-7) - The residue of replacing a lot of players through graduation and injuries.


2010 (10-3) - Included in the victory column was a 28-27 win over Notre Dame in South Bend.  Offense averaged 506 ypg.  The defense led the nation with 24 INT's and was third nationally in turnovers gained with a margin of +36.


2011 (6-6) - Graham got a late start at Pitt. Pitt's original hire after the firing of Dave Wannstedt was arrested for domestic violence immediately after being hired.  Honestly, I don't know why the Pitt athletic director was so quick in firing Dave Wannstedt.  After beginning his tenure with records of 5-6, 6-6, and 5-7, he put together a nice string of 9-4, 10-3, and 8-5 before getting the axe.


Wannstedt ran a pro-style offense that was quite different than the offense being instituted by Todd Graham.  Problematic for Graham and Pitt was that 4 of their 6 losses were by a total of 14 points.  In 5 of the 6 losses, Pitt actually had a lead in the 4th quarter.


Pitt's Total Offense in 2011 was ranked #82 at 360 ypg .  The Panther's averaged 26 ppg (#65).  Quite a drop from the numbers that Todd Graham teams have been used to compiling.  Their red-zone scoring % was 92% for a national rank of #6.  

Defensively, you see a marked contrast with the offense.  Pitt was ranked #29 in points allowed at 22 ppg.  Total yards given up was 353 ypgs for a rank of #35.  Odd stats on defense included a #9 ranking in 3rd down conversion of 32% but a rank of #93 in defensive red-zone scoring % of 87%.  


2.  In Graham's first season at Rice, he experienced a 4 game losing streak to begin the season.  As mentioned previously, Rice was very much undermanned in those games against Houston (1 pt loss), UCLA (10 pt loss), Texas, and Florida State.


In 2008, Tulsa under Graham had one losing streak of 2 games.  In 2009, Tulsa experienced a six game losing streak.


During the 2011 season, Pitt under Graham had two losing streaks of 2 games.


In Todd Graham's short tenure as a head coach, he has not experienced two consecutive losing seasons.


3.  Graham took a different route than most in becoming a head coach at the university level.  In fact, the path he took is not much different than that of Rich Rodriguez.  Very few years as an assistant coach prior to becoming a head coach.


Graham was a all-state defensive back in the state of Texas and graduated in 1983.  He went on to play at Eastern Central University in Ada, Oklahoma and was a two-time All NAIA defensive back.  After graduation he spent enough time with the Arizona Cardinals to experience a cup of coffee.

In 1988, Graham began his coaching carerr as an assistant coach at Poteet HS in his hometown of Mesquite, Texas.  He later held head coaching positions at Carl Albert HS in Midwest City, Okl and Allen HS in Allen, Texas.

In 2001, Rich Rodriguez brought Graham onto his staff at West Virginia as LB's coach.  In 2002, Graham was assigned by Rodriguez to be a defensive co-coordinator.  That year the West Virginia defense was ranked #4 in the nation in turnover margin (+19).

In 2003, Graham was hired by Steve Kragthorpe to be the defensive coordinator for University of Tulsa.  In his three years as defensive coordinator, Tulsa had the reputation as having the best defensive unit in Conference USA and was nationally ranked in several defensive categories.  In 2003, the Tulsa defense was ranked #3 in take-aways, #3 in INT's, #11 in pass efficiency defense.

After three years at Tulsa, Graham accepted his first head coaching position at Rice University.

Although Todd Graham never coached with or was coached by ex-ASU head coach John Cooper, he considers Cooper to be a mentor of which he holds high regard.  In his whirlwind experience of accepting the job at ASU, Cooper gave Todd Graham this bit of advice.

Graham asked Cooper about working at ASU, the pluses, the minuses, and if he had any regrets.  Cooper stated to him that his biggest regret was leaving ASU for Ohio State.  He said they were worlds apart.  At ASU, he was the top dog.  Pressure was high but nothing like he experienced at Ohio State.  For the most part it was laid back, pretty good booster support.  The only problem was that the AD and the President at that time did not have a priority in football.  (It was common knowledge that AD Charles Harris and Pres J Russell Nelson were intent on minimizing athletics at ASU.  They had this illusion that less emphasis on athletics would equate to more emphasis and prestige in the academic realm.  That was the beginning of ASU's move towards mediocrity in which ASU has yet to recover..MLF)


Cooper told Graham that the pressure at OSU was like being in a pressure cooker 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.  Cooper told him that if you get the chance to coach at ASU, don't make the same mistake that he did and leave.  He said "take the program to greatness, which is something I should have done."

4.  Graham's record at his different stops shows a preference to a multi-faceted offense.  In some games he will transition between spread option to more of a pro-style attack.  Even during the Tulsa years of high octane offense, he was 50-50 on the run-pass.  At Pitt, his top RB had rushed for over 1,000 yards in the first 7 games and then got injured for the remainder of the season.  The Pitt QB was an erratic passer, thus he was finding comfort in the run until the pieces of that plan broke.

Similar to Rich Rodriguez,  Graham initially began his career as a proponent of the 3-3-5 defense.  In recent years he has transitioned more to a standard 4-3-4.  He states that he hopes to have a defense that can alternate between different fronts within the context of a single game.  Graham has experienced success on the defensive side of the ball while coaching in an offense happy league.

Not sure what type of success his teams had on the special teams front.  Traditionally his teams have been quite disciplined in that penalties and penalty yardage have been consistently low.

 5.  In Todd Graham's six seasons as a head coach, his record in games decided by 7 points or less is 17-13.  At Rice, he was 5-1.  Quite revealing in that this squad won a total of 7 games, thus five of the wins were nail-biters.  At Tulsa, his overall record in close games is 10-8.  Close games were not his friend during his only season at Pitt, where he won 2 and lost 4.

So, how would I categorize the hiring of Todd Graham?  It is important to not associate Todd Graham's record with the abysmal coaching search that took place prior to him being hired.  As stated in a previous email (that many of you received), of all the names that were considered as possible hires I would consider Todd Graham to be #2 on my list.  ASU has been a mediocre football program for quite some time.  The athletic department has been a mess for longer than that.  Considering where I feared this search may lead, I feel that Todd Graham is as good a hire as ASU could have at this moment in time. He is a definite upgrade over the staff that was let go.  In my opinion, the success or failure of the football program is dependent on the future of the athletic department.  If the AD personnel is not upgraded, then the football program will not have a sustained upgrade.

No comments:

Post a Comment