This is an edited article from my favorite economist, John Mauldin. He has a lot to say about what is happening in Europe and shares some needed advice on how the USA could get ourselves out of the current economic mess we are in. Europe is setting a great example of what NOT to do, and the imbeciles in power are doing just that?
The Seen and the Unseen
"In the economic sphere an act, a habit, an institution, a law produces not only one effect, but a series of effects. Of these effects, the first alone is immediate; it appears simultaneously with its cause; it is seen. The other effects emerge only subsequently; they are not seen; we are fortunate if we foresee them.
"There is only one difference between a bad economist and a good one: the bad economist confines himself to the visible effect; the good economist takes into account both the effect that can be seen and those effects that must be foreseen.
- From an essay by Frédéric Bastiat in 1850, "That Which Is Seen and That Which Is Unseen"
I have been captivated by the concept of the seen and the unseen in
economics since I was first introduced to the idea. It is a seminal part
of my understanding of economics, at least the small part I do grasp.
The idea was first written about by Frédéric Bastiat, who was a French
classical liberal theorist, political economist, and member of the
French assembly. He was notable for developing the important economic
concept of opportunity cost. He was a strong influence on von Mises,
Murray Rothbard, Henry Hazlitt, and even my friend Ron Paul. He was a
strong proponent of limited government and free trade, but he also
advocated that subsidies (read, stimulus?) should be available for those
in need, "... for urgent cases, the State should set aside some
resources to assist certain unfortunate people, to help them adjust to
changing conditions."
Today we'll explore a few things we can see and then try to foresee a
few things that are not so obvious. This is a condensation of a speech I
gave earlier this afternoon in Singapore for OCBC Bank, called "The
Lion in the Grass." The simple premise is that it is not the lions we
can see that are the problem; but rather, in trying to avoid them, it is
often the lions hidden in the grass that we stumble upon that become
the unwelcome surprise.
The Lion in the Grass
Let's go back and look at Bastiat's first sentence:"In the economic sphere an act, a habit, an institution, a law produces not only one effect, but a series of effects. Of these effects, the first alone is immediate; it appears simultaneously with its cause; it is seen. The other effects emerge only subsequently; they are not seen; we are fortunate if we foresee them."
I really can't remember when I first began to ponder the concept of the Lion in the Grass, although I have never used it in a letter. But during my Tuscany escape I thought about it a great deal, and I think it is a very useful analogy for today's world, and in the light of Bastiat's insight some 162 years ago.
It is natural to the human condition to focus on the apparent
dangers in front of us. That is part of our evolutionary heritage from
the time when humans were first dodging lions and chasing antelopes on
the African savannah. But we soon learned that if
we were to survive it was not enough to walk away from and around the
lions we could see. We also had to make sure we didn't walk into a lion
hidden in the grass. It is the hidden lions that can spring on us suddenly and take an arm or a leg.
Above, I have once again reproduced the picture. I even knew there was
a hidden lion and could not find it. But after it was pointed out to
me, it is now the first thing I see. And there is a direct analogy
there, to both economics and investing.
The hidden lion is now the first thing I see. And that
is the way with economic lions in the grass. Once someone points one
out, it's obvious. So obvious, that we soon convince ourselves that we
would have seen the lion without help. How many people told you they
"knew" all along that subprime debt was going to end in tears, or that
the housing market was a bubble? Or that we would be plunged into the
Great Recession?
I remember, in the fall of 2006 I was beginning to talk about the
probability of a recession, in this letter, in speeches, and in numerous
media interviews. I was told I was ignoring what the market was
telling us, and indeed the market proceeded to go up for another six
months. Being early is lonely.
Black Swan or Hidden Lion?
I should note that a Lion in the Grass is different from a Black Swan. A Black Swan is a random event, something that takes us all by surprise. Economic Black Swans are actually quite rare. 9/11 and the aftermath was a true Black Swan.The last recession and the credit crisis were not true Black Swans. There were those who saw it all coming, but few paid attention. They were dancing right along with Chuck Prince to the rousing music of a bull market and swelling profits.
As we know now, a lot of people saw the subprime crisis coming and a few made huge fortunes. Sadly, it generally required one to risk a small fortune to play in that game. But it's different with hidden lions. If you can spot one, and figure out how to stalk it, there can be large profits betting on that which is unseen by the markets.
So, now let's quickly look at a few lions we can see and then try to spot a few that are hidden close by.
The Lions of Europe
Everyone now knows that there are lions roaming all over Europe. When I (and a fast-swelling group of other observers) started writing about Greece, we were at first told that developed countries simply could not default in the modern era. Indeed, European banking regulators had allowed (implicitly encouraged?) European banks to buy peripheral-country bonds and required them to post no reserves against those bonds. It was "free money" to the banks. You could pay a few points on deposits and then leverage them up to 40 times, getting up to 3-4% carry, depending on how far out the yield curve you wanted to go. 100% risk-free returns on your capital. Who wouldn't go for that? And it had to be risk-free, because the regulators said so.
And when Endgame came out in the spring of 2011, we got a
lot of pushback for saying that Spain would get in serious trouble and
have to "restructure" its debt. How could that be? By that time one had
to admit that it was possible Greece might have problems. But Spain? We
were told that Spain was a "real country." Real countries did not
default. (Forget that Greece, only a few years earlier, had been
considered real enough to be admitted to the eurozone.) Spain was
different.
(You have to feel sorry for the guy. He is sincere, but he is doggedly riding a very ailing horse as he tilts at the debt windmill. Cue the song "To Dream the Impossible Dream." The line "To fight the unbeatable foe" comes to mind. There is just too much Spanish debt, and the requirement to keep cutting the deficit will just make that hole deeper and the foe even more fearsome when the final battle lines are drawn.)
We can all see the lions, large and small, of Greece, Portugal, Ireland, Spain, Italy, and now Cypress and Malta. The fear of contagion is what keeps European leaders up at night, trying to figure out how to keep Spain afloat. Because if Spain sinks, the focus immediately turns to Italy.
The woes of Greece, Spain, et al. have been chronicled in this
letter and indeed almost everywhere. So let's just look at one chart and
then move on. This is from my friend Chris Wood, writing in GREED and fear. Notice how much capital is leaving Spain each month. The outflows are now massive.
But enough of the lions we can see. Don't look now, but the lion that
lies hidden in the grass is France. Yes, the France that is supposedly a
big part of the solution to eurozone woes and Germany's stalwart
partner in guaranteeing all that debt. AAA France.
France deserves (and will soon get) its own full letter. But while
you are waiting, let me highlight a few thoughts.
First, let's look at
this chart from the IMF, examining the debt prospects of six countries
(The entire study was of 18 countries.) The dotted lines are three paths
that the debt-to-GDP ratio can follow.
The top line is the trajectory
without any actions by the individual governments.
The middle dotted
line is what the debt trajectory would look like with mild reforms to
entitlements.
The bottom line is the debt trajectory if very
draconian measures are taken.
See if you can spot the hidden lion by
guessing which country's debt situation looks most like France's.
So, what has been the response of the new French government? It
has decided to double down on what was already an irresponsible path. Do
you think the average German understands just how bad off their
"partner" is? For that matter, do you think the average French
politician understands how bad off France is? Certainly not the majority
of them, and it is doubtful that their counterparts in Germany do,
either. This is going to be a train wreck of biblical
proportions. Think 12 plagues, not the run of the mill 10.
Hollande evidently has very good political instincts and knows how to
work the system. Unfortunately, he has the economic understanding that
God gave a goose. Someone should sit him down and make him read all of
Bastiat's essays. (It might just be too much to ask a French Socialist
politician to read an English or Austrian economist who actually
understood how things work.)
Let's look at what Hollande has done in his first month. He lowered the
retirement age from the 62 that Sarkozy was barely able to get it up to,
back to the ripe old age of 60. He has raised the taxes on those making
over €1 million to 75%. He is raising the wealth tax on those whose
have a net worth of over €4 million to double what they were expecting.
This is called the contribution exceptionnelle sur la fortune. No
translation is needed. You think a few people might decide to move to
Spain? Or Switzerland? Capital will go to where it is loved and wanted.
And those with a little wealth cannot be feeling a lot of love, if they
are in France.
Note that the contribution exceptionnelle is on net worth, not on
income. But the politicians promise it is just for the current
emergency. It can go back down when the crisis is over. Except that
France is getting ready to enter a permanent crisis. Can you see which
direction this is heading? Can you see which direction the wealthier
French citizen is headed? You can get a reservation in a good French
bistro these days if you live in London. Just saying...
The newly appointed, radical, and Orwellian-named Minister of
Productive Recovery is calling every company that plans to reduce its
payroll to avoid losses and telling it that it must negotiate with labor
and figure out how to keep losing money. The unions are in the streets.
Oh, and large corporations will also have to pay more taxes. And don't
even think about moving "French jobs" out of the country.
The list goes on. This flies in the face of the IMF study (and many others) that shows France is at the edge of a fiscal cliff with its entitlement programs. And taxes already consume 50% of GDP. Deficits are high and rising, and raising taxes even more will not result in actually collecting more taxes. Ask England how much they got when the passed a tax surcharge on the wealthy: tax revenues from the rich went down. An increase of only a few percent, and at some point the rich vote with their feet.
Germany has almost got its head around the fact that it will have to bail out Spain. Does anyone think German voters will go along with bailing out the French? What happens when the markets realize that France is essentially bankrupt and cannot print its own currency? And that all the policies that this new government wants to enact will only make things worse? And that Hollande will be in power for at least four years?
We will explore this idea in future letters, but I would suggest that if France becomes an economic problem on the order of Spain, it will be very disruptive. Bailing out France may be a bridge too far, even for a stolid europhile like Merkel.
What If the US Trade Balance Became a Surplus?
We can all see that shale oil is a growing business. US oil production is rising, even as consumption is dropping due to more efficient use of oil. You can easily find projections that within 10 years the US could be energy-independent. And if we get some policies that allow more wells to be drilled (which could create another 1 million jobs) it could happen even sooner!That will narrow the trade deficit but not eliminate it. But...
What if we find a way to take our huge natural gas supply and send it abroad? Natural gas is about $2 today. There are supposedly 10,000 wells that have been capped and very few new wells are being drilled. Natural gas is just too cheap in the US. But it was recently $17 in Japan, and almost that in Europe. Even I can see an arbitrage there. There is certainly enough global demand to allow the US to sell enough natural gas to further reduce or even eliminate the trade deficit (again, depending on the national policies we set).
That is the lion we can see. But what happens if we stop sending
our "surplus" dollars into the world? A growing world will need more
dollars to finance global trade. And to buy our exports. The lion that
is hidden is that the dollar would become seriously strong. Today,
everyone and his uncle is predicting the demise of the dollar (along
with other fiat currencies). But what if we actually got our deficit act
together and combined that with a real energy policy? That sounds
rather Pollyanish today, but it is totally within the realm of
possibility.




No comments:
Post a Comment